Brill’s Encyclopedia of Buddhism
Volume II:
Lives
Editor-in-chief
Jonathan A. Silk
Editors
Richard Bowring
Vincent Eltschinger
Michael Radich
Editorial Advisory Board
Lucia Dolce
Berthe Jansen
John Jorgensen
Christian Lammerts
Francesco Sferra
LEIDEN | BOSTON
For use by the Author only | © 2019 Koninklijke Brill NV
Contents
Prelims
Contributors .............................................................................................................................................................
xi
Editors and Editorial Board .................................................................................................................................. xxxiii
Primary Sources Abbreviations........................................................................................................................... xxxv
Books Series and Journals Abbreviations ......................................................................................................... xxxvii
General Abbreviations ..........................................................................................................................................
xlii
Introduction .............................................................................................................................................................
xliv
Section One:
Śākyamuni: South Asia ..........................................................................................................................................
Barlaam and Josaphat ............................................................................................................................................
3
39
Section Two:
South & Southeast Asia:
Ajātaśatru ..................................................................................................................................................................
Āryadeva....................................................................................................................................................................
Āryaśūra.....................................................................................................................................................................
Asaṅga/Maitreya(nātha).......................................................................................................................................
Bhāviveka ..................................................................................................................................................................
Brahmā, Śakra, and Māra ......................................................................................................................................
Buddhaghoṣa............................................................................................................................................................
Buddhas of the Past: South Asia .........................................................................................................................
Buddhas of the Past and of the Future: Southeast Asia ...............................................................................
Candragomin ...........................................................................................................................................................
Candrakīrti................................................................................................................................................................
Ḍākinī .........................................................................................................................................................................
Devadatta ..................................................................................................................................................................
Dharmakīrti ..............................................................................................................................................................
Dharmapāla ..............................................................................................................................................................
Dharmottara.............................................................................................................................................................
Dignāga ......................................................................................................................................................................
Early Sarvāstivāda Masters ...................................................................................................................................
Gavampati in Southeast Asia ...............................................................................................................................
Gopadatta .................................................................................................................................................................
Guṇaprabha..............................................................................................................................................................
Haribhadra................................................................................................................................................................
Haribhaṭṭa .................................................................................................................................................................
Harivarman...............................................................................................................................................................
Harṣa ..........................................................................................................................................................................
Hayagrīva...................................................................................................................................................................
Indian Tantric Authors: Overview ......................................................................................................................
Jñānagarbha .............................................................................................................................................................
Jñānapāda .................................................................................................................................................................
© Koninklijke Brill NV, Leiden, 2019
Also available online – www.brill.com
For use by the Author only | © 2019 Koninklijke Brill NV
51
60
70
73
81
85
92
95
109
121
125
132
141
156
168
173
179
186
191
196
198
204
209
211
214
218
228
261
264
BEB, vol. II
vi
Contents
Jñānaśrīmitra ...........................................................................................................................................................
Kamalaśīla ................................................................................................................................................................
Karuṇāmaya .............................................................................................................................................................
Kṣemendra ................................................................................................................................................................
Kumāralāta ...............................................................................................................................................................
Mahādeva..................................................................................................................................................................
Maitreya.....................................................................................................................................................................
Mārīcī .........................................................................................................................................................................
Mātṛceṭa ....................................................................................................................................................................
Nāgārjuna ..................................................................................................................................................................
Paccekabuddhas/Pratyekabuddhas in Indic Sources ...................................................................................
Phra Malai in Thailand and Southeast Asia.....................................................................................................
Prajñākaragupta ......................................................................................................................................................
Ratnākaraśānti.........................................................................................................................................................
Ratnakīrti ..................................................................................................................................................................
Saṅghabhadra ..........................................................................................................................................................
Śaṅkaranandana .....................................................................................................................................................
Śaṅkarasvāmin ........................................................................................................................................................
Śāntarakṣita ..............................................................................................................................................................
Śāntideva ...................................................................................................................................................................
Sarasvatī/Benzaiten................................................................................................................................................
Śāriputra ....................................................................................................................................................................
Scholars of Premodern Pali Buddhism .............................................................................................................
Seers (ṛṣi/isi) and Brāhmaṇas in Southeast Asia ............................................................................................
Siddhas.......................................................................................................................................................................
Śrīlāta .........................................................................................................................................................................
Sthiramati .................................................................................................................................................................
Śubhagupta...............................................................................................................................................................
Tantric Buddhist Deities in Southeast Asia .....................................................................................................
Thera/Therī in Pali and Southeast Asian Buddhism .....................................................................................
Udbhaṭasiddhasvāmin ..........................................................................................................................................
Upagupta ...................................................................................................................................................................
Vāgīśvarakīrti ...........................................................................................................................................................
Vasubandhu ..............................................................................................................................................................
Vināyaka ....................................................................................................................................................................
Yama and Hell Beings in Indian Buddhism .....................................................................................................
269
272
279
286
293
298
302
325
332
335
348
357
363
366
371
374
378
382
383
391
398
409
420
437
443
452
456
458
463
474
479
481
490
492
507
513
East Asia:
Ākāśagarbha in East Asia ......................................................................................................................................
Arhats in East Asian Buddhism ..........................................................................................................................
Aśvaghoṣa (East Asian Aspects) .........................................................................................................................
Avalokiteśvara in East Asia...................................................................................................................................
Dizang/Jizō ...............................................................................................................................................................
Jianzhen (Ganjin) ...................................................................................................................................................
Mahākāla in East Asia............................................................................................................................................
Mahākāśyapa in Chan-inspired Traditions......................................................................................................
Mañjuśrī in East Asia .............................................................................................................................................
Maudgalyāyana (Mulian)......................................................................................................................................
Musang (Wuxiang) .................................................................................................................................................
Tejaprabhā ................................................................................................................................................................
Yinyuan Longqi (Ingen) ........................................................................................................................................
For use by the Author only | © 2019 Koninklijke Brill NV
521
529
540
546
562
571
576
586
591
600
608
612
616
Contents
vii
China:
Amoghavajra ............................................................................................................................................................
An Shigao ..................................................................................................................................................................
Chengguan ................................................................................................................................................................
Daoxuan ....................................................................................................................................................................
Falin ............................................................................................................................................................................
Faxian .........................................................................................................................................................................
Fazun ..........................................................................................................................................................................
Hanshan Deqing .....................................................................................................................................................
Hongzhi Zhengjue ..................................................................................................................................................
Huihong (see Juefan Huihong)
Huineng (see Shenxiu)
Huiyuan (see Lushan Huiyuan)
Jigong..........................................................................................................................................................................
Juefan Huihong .......................................................................................................................................................
Liang Wudi................................................................................................................................................................
Lokakṣema ................................................................................................................................................................
Luo Qing ....................................................................................................................................................................
Lushan Huiyuan ......................................................................................................................................................
Mazu Daoyi...............................................................................................................................................................
Mingben (see Zhongfeng Mingben)
Nāgārjuna in China ................................................................................................................................................
Nenghai......................................................................................................................................................................
Ouyang Jingwu ........................................................................................................................................................
Ouyi Zhixu ................................................................................................................................................................
Paramārtha ...............................................................................................................................................................
Qian Qianyi...............................................................................................................................................................
Qisong ........................................................................................................................................................................
Shenhui (see Shenxiu)
Shenxiu, Huineng, and Shenhui .........................................................................................................................
Śubhākarasiṃha......................................................................................................................................................
Wumen ......................................................................................................................................................................
Wuxiang (see East Asia: Musang)
Wuzhu ........................................................................................................................................................................
Xiao Ziliang...............................................................................................................................................................
Yinshun......................................................................................................................................................................
Yixing .........................................................................................................................................................................
Yuan Hongdao .........................................................................................................................................................
Yuanwu Keqin ..........................................................................................................................................................
Zhanran .....................................................................................................................................................................
Zhi Qian .....................................................................................................................................................................
Zhili.............................................................................................................................................................................
Zhixu (see Ouyang Zhixu)
Zhiyi............................................................................................................................................................................
Zhongfeng Mingben...............................................................................................................................................
Zhuhong ....................................................................................................................................................................
623
630
642
648
653
657
662
668
673
679
684
689
700
707
711
722
727
735
741
748
752
759
764
768
777
782
787
791
795
800
806
810
814
818
826
833
839
844
Korea:
Chinul.........................................................................................................................................................................
Hyujŏng .....................................................................................................................................................................
Ich’adon .....................................................................................................................................................................
For use by the Author only | © 2019 Koninklijke Brill NV
853
860
864
viii
Contents
Kihwa .........................................................................................................................................................................
Kim Sisŭp ..................................................................................................................................................................
Kyŏnghŏ.....................................................................................................................................................................
Kyunyŏ .......................................................................................................................................................................
Muhak Chach’o ........................................................................................................................................................
Musang (see East Asia)
Pou ..............................................................................................................................................................................
Tosŏn ..........................................................................................................................................................................
Ŭich’ŏn .......................................................................................................................................................................
Ŭisang ........................................................................................................................................................................
Wŏnch’ŭk ..................................................................................................................................................................
Wŏnhyo......................................................................................................................................................................
Yi Nŭnghwa ..............................................................................................................................................................
869
873
877
882
887
891
895
900
903
908
913
918
Japan:
Amaterasu Ōmikami ..............................................................................................................................................
Annen.........................................................................................................................................................................
Benzaiten (see South and Southeast Asia: Sarasvatī)
Dōgen .........................................................................................................................................................................
Dōhan.........................................................................................................................................................................
Eisai (see Yōsai)
Eison ...........................................................................................................................................................................
En no Gyōja ..............................................................................................................................................................
Enchin ........................................................................................................................................................................
Ennin ..........................................................................................................................................................................
Ganjin (see East Asia: Jianzhen)
Genshin .....................................................................................................................................................................
Hachiman .................................................................................................................................................................
Hakuin .......................................................................................................................................................................
Hōnen ........................................................................................................................................................................
Ikkyū Sōjun ...............................................................................................................................................................
Ingen (see East Asia: Yinyuan Longqi)
Ippen Chishin ..........................................................................................................................................................
Jakushō ......................................................................................................................................................................
Jiun Sonja ..................................................................................................................................................................
Jizō (see East Asia: Dizang)
Jōjin.............................................................................................................................................................................
Jōkei ............................................................................................................................................................................
Kakuban ....................................................................................................................................................................
Keizan Jōkin .............................................................................................................................................................
Kōmyō ........................................................................................................................................................................
Kūkai ..........................................................................................................................................................................
Kūya ............................................................................................................................................................................
Menzan Zuihō .........................................................................................................................................................
Monkan .....................................................................................................................................................................
Mugai Nyodai ...........................................................................................................................................................
Mujaku Dōchū .........................................................................................................................................................
Musō Soseki ..............................................................................................................................................................
Myōe ...........................................................................................................................................................................
Nichiren .....................................................................................................................................................................
Nōnin..........................................................................................................................................................................
For use by the Author only | © 2019 Koninklijke Brill NV
923
930
933
941
944
951
956
961
967
971
976
980
987
991
995
998
1002
1006
1011
1016
1020
1026
1036
1041
1047
1057
1062
1066
1071
1076
1088
Contents
Raiyu...........................................................................................................................................................................
Ryōgen........................................................................................................................................................................
Saichō .........................................................................................................................................................................
Saigyō .........................................................................................................................................................................
Shinran.......................................................................................................................................................................
Shōtoku Taishi .........................................................................................................................................................
Tenjin .........................................................................................................................................................................
Tenkai .........................................................................................................................................................................
Yōsai/Eisai .................................................................................................................................................................
Zaō ..............................................................................................................................................................................
ix
1094
1097
1102
1107
1111
1117
1122
1128
1134
1139
Tibetan Cultural Sphere
Atiśa and the Bka’ gdams pa Masters ................................................................................................................
Ge sar of Gling .........................................................................................................................................................
Gter ston: Tibetan Buddhist Treasure Revealers .............................................................................................
Gtsang smyon Heruka ...........................................................................................................................................
Lcang skya Rol pa’i Rdo rje ...................................................................................................................................
Mi la ras pa................................................................................................................................................................
The Mongolian Jebdzundamba Khutugtu Lineage .......................................................................................
Padmasambhava in Tibetan Buddhism ............................................................................................................
The Sa skya School’s Five Forefathers................................................................................................................
Spirits of the Soil, Land, and Locality in Tibet ................................................................................................
Ston pa Gshen rab: The Bön Buddha .................................................................................................................
Tibet's Crazy Yogins ................................................................................................................................................
Tsong kha pa and his Immediate Successors ..................................................................................................
Worldly Protector Deities in Tibet .....................................................................................................................
1145
1159
1165
1171
1175
1181
1191
1197
1213
1226
1233
1239
1246
1254
Appendix To Volume I:
Buddhist Narrative Literature in Japan .............................................................................................................
Poetry: Japan ............................................................................................................................................................
Korean Sŏn Literature............................................................................................................................................
For use by the Author only | © 2019 Koninklijke Brill NV
1269
1286
1294
Yixing
The Tang period monk Yixing (一行; 673/683–727) is
known as an astronomer, calendar reformer, Yijing
(易經) specialist, and eminent Buddhist monk with
expertise in Chan, Mantrayāna, and the Vinaya. In
the Buddhist context he is best known for his role
in translating the Mahāvairocana-sūtra and later
writing the definitive commentary to that text. In
the secular context, he is known for reforming the
state calendar. As a result of these historical roles,
in the late Tang there emerged a legendary image
of Yixing as an adept astrologer and practitioner of
astral magic, with several astrological texts attributed to him.
Sources
A number of sources on Yixing’s life provide both
plausible biographical information and legendary
tales. The earliest datable source is a copy of his
memorial stele made by →Kūkai (空海; 774–835),
preserved in the Shingon fuhō den (眞言付法傳;
also titled Ryaku fuhō den [略付法傳]; Kōbō Daishi
zenshū [弘法大師全集], 1911, vol. I, 63–65). Here
he is described as an erudite monk with a focus
on his monastic career. The Naishō Buppō sōshō
kechimyakufu (内證佛法相承血脈譜) of 819 and the
Taizō engi (胎藏緣起) by →Saichō (最澄; 767–822)
provide accounts of his life, with the latter being
more detailed (Dengyō Daishi zenshū [傳教大師全
集], 1926, vol. I, 238–242; vol. IV, 387–393). Chapter 29 of the Tang xinyu (唐新語) by Liu Su (劉肅;
fl. 820) lists some of his works related to calendars
and astronomy, in addition to providing some brief
biographical details (1035.398). One major source
of Yixing’s life is his biography included in the Jiu
Tang shu (舊唐書, Old Tang History), compiled in
945 by Liu Xu (劉昫; 887–946). It is listed under the
arts (fang ji [方伎]; fasc. 191) section and remembers his achievements in astronomy. The sections
on calendar reforms and astronomy (fasc. 32, 35)
detail his work in those areas. The Xing Tang shu
(新唐書, New Tang History) of 1060 by Ouyang Xiu
(歐陽修; 1007–1072) and Song Qi (宋祁; 998–1061)
includes more materials on his calendar (fasc. 27,
28). The Song Gaoseng zhuan (宋高僧傳; T. 2061 [L]
732c7–733c24) of 988 by Zanning (贊寧; 920–1001)
provides additional stories about his life. The Shimen zhengtong (釋門正統; X. 1513 [LXXV] 364b17–
c22) of 1257 by Zongjian (宗鑑; d. 1206) provides
a biography largely identical to that in the Song
Gaoseng zhuan but states that he died at the age of
55 (rather than forty-five as in other sources), which
results in the dates 673–727. Other later accounts
of Yixing are based on the Song Gaoseng zhuan.
Portraits of Yixing based on a Chinese original by
painter Li Zhen (李真; fl. 780–805) survive in Japan
(Shi, 1976).
In the early 8th century there lived another monk
identically named Yixing (d.u.) from Zhulin si (竹林
寺) in Hangzhou (杭州), who was proficient in geomancy. He is identified, however, as a Chan monk
who served under Huilang (慧朗; 662–725). Various
works in later catalogs on geomancy-related subjects attributed to “Yixing” are to be credited instead
of this other Yixing (Lü, 2009, 349).
Modern scholarship on Yixing focuses on either
his Buddhist career or his work in astronomy. As
to major secondary sources, the monograph by
Osabe Kazuo (1963) is the most detailed study to
date as it surveys his religious career and discusses
in detail his work with the Yijing, but it lacks a
detailed analysis of his contribution to astronomy.
Lü Jianfu (1995) covers Yixing’s biography and Buddhist career. Chen (2000–2001) reconstructs Yixing’s
genealogy. An early study of Yixing’s work in astronomy in English was undertaken by Needham and
Wang Ling in volume III of Science and Civilisation
in China (Needham & Wang, 1959, 37–38, 270–271,
282–283). Yabuuchi (1989, 32–40) outlines Yixing’s
work on the state calendar. Ohashi (2011) examines
the mathematics in Yixing’s calendar. Kotyk (2017)
discusses Yixing’s role in Tang Buddhist astrology.
Further study of Yixing’s work with the Yijing is
necessary.
Yixing’s Life
Yixing was born as Zhang Sui (張遂) in Changle
(昌樂) in Weizhou (魏州), modern Nanle (南樂) in
Hebei, though some sources state his place of birth
© Koninklijke Brill NV, Leiden, 2019
Also available online – www.brill.com
For use by the Author only | © 2019 Koninklijke Brill NV
BEB, vol. II
Yixing
as Julu (鉅鹿), modern Pingxiang (平鄉), Hebei. He
was a great-grandson of Zhang Gongjin (張公謹;
584–632), an influential political figure during the
early years of the Tang dynasty. Chen (2000–2001)
investigated his genealogy, which indicates that
he hailed from a prestigious clan with early connections to Dunhuang. Yixing’s family background
was also possibly a factor in his recruitment by the
Emperor Xuanzong (玄宗; 685–762, r. 713–756) who,
after the reestablishment of the Tang following Wu
Zetian’s (武則天; 624–705) short-lived Zhou dynasty
(690–705), sought to strengthen his position by
drawing on descendants of old Tang loyalists. The
Jiu Tang shu states that in his youth he was exceptionally intelligent, reading the classics with a particular interest in astronomy, calendrical science,
and traditional Chinese metaphysics (yinyang [陰
陽] and five elements [五行] theory).
The Taizō engi records that when Yixing was 21,
both his parents died, and he subsequently felt
compelled to reject the worldly life. He met Hongjing (弘景; 634–712; also called Hengjing [恆景])
in Jingzhou (荊州), and he provided instruction
and inspired Yixing to become a monk. He further
received instruction from Facheng (法誠; d.u.) of
Huagan si (化感寺). In 707, Yixing arrived in the
eastern capital (Luoyang [洛陽]) and received full
precepts. He is said to have borrowed a copy of the
Prātimokṣa (precepts manual) and been able to
recite it from memory after one reading and moreover to have been quite diligent in his practice of
the Vinaya.
We are told in the Jiu Tang shu that Wu Sansi
(武三思; d. 707), a powerful minister and relative
of the Empress Wu Zetian, admired Yixing’s work
and requested a meeting, but Yixing fled and hid
himself away. This might have been what led him
to travel to Mount Song (嵩山), where he studied
Chan under Puji (普寂; 651–739), also known as
Dazhao Chanshi (大照禪師), who was widely recognized as the seventh patriarch of the Northern
Chan school. The Jingde chuandeng lu (景德傳燈
錄; T. 2076 [LI] 224c12) lists Yixing as one of the 46
dharma-heirs to Puji. The Taizō engi states that Yixing
constantly cultivated “single-practice samādhi”
(*ekavyūha-samādhi, yixing sanmei [一行三昧]),
which is the origin of his monastic name. As Chen
points out (2000–2001, 26–30), there is evidence
that Yixing was also a disciple of Shenxiu (神秀; d.
706), the master of Puji, based on the contents of a
letter addressed to Zhang Yue (張說; 667–731) that
is attributed to Yixing (dated 715–717), in which it
801
is stated that over ten years had passed since their
late teacher had died (Quan Tangwen [全唐文];
914.9525b–26a). The letter is an invitation to attend
a gathering at Dumen si (度門寺), an institution
established by Wu Zetian for Shenxiu. One of the
fellow monks mentioned in the letter, Damo (達摩;
d.u.), was also known as a disciple of Shenxiu.
The Taizō engi and the Jiu Tang shu report that
after Emperor Ruizong (睿宗; 662–716) ascended
the throne in 710, Yixing was ordered to meet with
the statesman Wei Anshi (韋安石; 651–714), but
Yixing excused himself on account of illness. Yixing
spent the next several years wandering in more
southern areas, seeking out eminent monks and
constantly on the move. He later moved to Mount
Dangyang (當陽山) where he studied the “Indian
Vinaya” (梵律) under Wuzhen (悟眞; 673–751; also
called Huizhen [惠眞]). It seems it was around this
time that he intensively studied Vinaya works, compiling a work explaining the essentials of the Vinaya
entitled Tiaofu zang (調伏藏) in ten fascicles (not
extant). The Jiu Tang shu (191.5112) lists a similar text
by Yixing entitled She tiaofu zang (攝調伏藏). He
also received training under the monk Daoyi (道一;
679–754), according to an epitaph by Li Hua (李華;
b. 715; Quan Tangwen, 319.3233a–35a).
The Taizō engi reports that in the year 716, Yixing
was staying at Mount Yuquan (玉泉山). Emperor
Xuanzong commanded Zhang Qia (張洽; d.u.) –
the paternal younger male cousin of Yixing’s father
(Chen, 2000–2001, 12) – to personally go and invite
Yixing to the capital in 717. Yixing arrived in the
capital and we are told in the Jiu Tang shu that he
was often visited, presumably by the emperor, who
asked about ways of securing the country and placating the people.
According to the Taizō engi, in autumn of 727
Yixing fell ill and started taking medicine, but it
proved ineffective and the symptoms worsened. The
venerable monks of the capital built an altar and
both lay and monastic peoples gathered to carry out
recitations for his benefit while making continual
offerings. Gradually Yixing’s symptoms eased to the
delight of the masses. They organized a great feast
with offerings, incense, and music. Yixing accompanied the emperor on a trip but suddenly died at
Xinfeng (新豐) at the age of 45 or 55 (depending upon
which date of birth we accept, as discussed above).
Emperor Xuanzong personally composed the text
for his memorial stele. Although the non-Buddhist
sources primarily recall his achievements in astronomy, his posthumous title of Dahui Chanshi
For use by the Author only | © 2019 Koninklijke Brill NV
802
Yixing
(大慧禪師) conferred onto him by the emperor
reflects his status as an eminent monk.
Yixing in the Capital
Yixing spent the last decade of his life in the capitals Chang’an (長安) and Luoyang. In this period
his religious interest seems to have primarily been
in Mantrayāna (i.e. Esoteric Buddhism) under the
direction of the Indian masters →Śubhakarasiṃha
(善無畏; 637–735) and Vajrabodhi (金剛智; 671–741).
Yixing collaborated with the former to translate the
Mahāvairocana-sūtra. The Sanskrit source text that
they translated was that carried from India by a certain Chinese monk named Wuxing (無行; b. 630)
who had travelled to India and, while returning to
China, died in northern India. The texts he carried
were forwarded to China (Yamamoto, 2012, 88). The
Kaiyuan Shijiao lu (開元釋教錄; T. 2154 [LV] 572a21–
23) explains that Yixing and Śubhakarasiṃha found
the Mahāvairocana-sūtra among other texts at
Huayan si (華嚴寺) in Chang’an. In 724, the pair
moved to Luoyang, where they were housed at
Dafuxian si (大福先寺) and where they produced
their translation. The original Sanskrit text is said to
have included 100,000 verses. The Chinese translation excerpted the main components of the original work. The monk Baoyue (寶月; *Ratnacandra?;
fl. 724) translated the words of Śubhakarasiṃha,
and Yixing acted as scribe and editor. In light of this,
Yixing was not strictly a translator, which perhaps
indicates that Yixing was not proficient in Sanskrit.
In this respect it is worth noting that in the
Gishaku mokuroku (義釋目錄) by →Enchin (圓珍;
814–891) there is listed a Fanben Piluzhena chengfo
jing chaoji (梵本毗盧遮那成佛經抄記; X. 438
[XXIII] 522a21), which appears to have been notes
on the Sanskrit Mahāvairocana-sūtra. This might
have comprised some of the materials used by
Yixing in writing the authoritative commentary on
that sūtra, which is his most important Buddhist
work. There are two extant versions of this commentary: the Dari jing shu (大日經疏; T. 1796) and
Dari jing yishi (大日經義釋; X. 438). In Japan the latter is traditionally believed to be a revised version
by Zhiyan (智儼; d.u.) and Wengu (溫古; fl. 723),
although Shimizu (2008) disputes this. Yixing is said
to have “recorded” (ji [記]) the commentary rather
than to have written it. The text records the oral
explanations of Śubhakarasiṃha (cited as ācārya
[阿闍梨]), though Yixing’s own comments are also
indicated (si wei [私謂]), and the text furthermore
cites Chinese Buddhist texts. Hence there are multiple voices throughout the work.
Japanese scholars have differing opinions on the
attributed authorship of the commentary. Osabe
Kazuo notes that Tang-era biographies and catalogs do not mention the commentary (1954, 41).
The Japanese Sho ajari shingon mikkyō burui sōroku
(諸阿闍梨眞言密教部類總錄; T. 2176 [LV] 1114c20–
1115a5) by Annen (安然; b. 841) lists nine recensions
of the commentary, with only one ascribed to Yixing.
Kawamura (1959) notes the presence of seemingly
anachronistic elements reflective of later developments, but these might have been added to the commentary at a later time. Kameyama (2007) accepts
the attribution to Yixing and Śubhakarasiṃha. Two
extant prefaces and one Tang-era work mention
Yixing writing an exegesis to accompany the sūtra
(Mano, 2015, 218–219). The Taizō engi also mentions
this.
The commentary cites a number of translated
Chinese works. For example, the Da zhidu lun
(大智度論; T. 1509) alone is cited in the first chapter a total of 52 times (Katō, 1979, 735). There are
also many citations of Nāgārjuna’s *Madhyamakaśāstra (Zhong lun [中論]; T. 1564). The commentary furthermore displays a number of elements
drawn from Huayan (華嚴) philosophy and the
Buddhāvataṃsaka (Endō, 2007). The four main
points of the commentary discuss buddhahood in
a single lifetime (yisheng chengfo [一生成佛]); the
three mysteries of body, speech, and mind (sanmi
[三密]); grading the four vehicles according to the
single path (yidao sisheng panjiao [一道四乘判教]);
and the true characteristic of the mind (xin shixiang
[心實相]) (Keyworth, 2011, 343).
Yixing is also said to have received instruction
from Vajrabodhi. One account states that Yixing
sought the Vajraśekhara abhiṣeka from Vajrabodhi
after the latter arrived in Chang’an in 719 (T. 1798
[XXXIX] 808b25–26). Further, Yixing assisted
Vajrabodhi’s translation work.
The Jiu Tang shu (191.5112) lists a work by Yixing
entitled Shishi xilu (釋氏系錄) in one fascicle (not
extant), likely indicating it was a major work. The
Datang Zhenyuan xu kaiyuan Shijiao lu (大唐貞
元續開元釋教錄; T. 2156), a text catalog by Yuanzhao (圓照; fl. 8th cent.), states it has four articles
(T 2156 [LV) 765a6–10]: monastery administration
(gangwei tasi [綱維塔寺]), aims of teaching Dharma
(shuofa zhigui [說法旨歸]), seated meditation and
For use by the Author only | © 2019 Koninklijke Brill NV
Yixing
cultivation (zuochan xiuzheng [坐禪修證]), and
the three robes (san fafuyi [三法服衣]), along with
an appended article on procedures for the midday
meal (zhongzhai fa [中齋法]).
Yixing the Astronomer
Yixing is known in the Tang histories for his achievements in astronomy and calendrical science. His
greatest contribution to astronomy was the formulation of an innovative new calendar. The Jiu Tang
shu (35.1293) reports that in 721 the lack of accurate
eclipse predictions led the court to request Yixing
to reform the state calendar. He identified a need
to understand the movement of the ecliptic (the
apparent path of the sun across the sky) and to take
measurements in relation to it, but the problem was
that the court astronomers based their measurements on the celestial equator and possessed no
instrument to measure the ecliptic. Together with
the military engineer Liang Lingzan (梁令瓚; d.u.),
Yixing built a mechanical water-powered armillary sphere. Its construction was completed in 725.
Although it eventually rusted and ceased to operate, the instrument was used by Yixing to gather
critical measurements for formulating his calendar, the Dayan li (大衍曆). The Tongdian (通典),
compiled in 801 by Du You (杜佑; 735–812), gives an
account of Yixing and Nangong Yue (南宮說; d.u.)
analyzing the astronomical observations from various locations around the year 724 (26.156c). Yixing’s
calendar drew on the results of these investigations
while building on the work of earlier calendars that
had rapidly evolved throughout the Sui and early
Tang periods. His calendar had a number of innovative features including improved methods for solar
eclipse prediction, calculation of planetary positions, and a device to calculate length of daytime
shadows and the lengths of daytime and nighttime
across differing locations and seasons. His calendar also likely incorporated some Indian elements
(Ohashi, 2011, 172).
The Xin Tang shu (27a.587) states that although
other calendars were later adopted, they all emulated the Dayan li; thus this calendar was Yixing’s
most significant work on astronomy. It furthermore
states (25.533) that he was the first to specifically
employ number theory derived from the Yijing
(details in fasc. 27 of the Xin Tang shu). Text catalogs also indicate that Yixing wrote extensively on
803
the Yijing, and Osabe (1963, 124) identifies seven
non-extant texts by or attributed to Yixing: Zhouyi
lun (周易論), Zixia Yi zhuan (子夏易傳), Jingfang
Yi zhuan (京房易傳), Yi zuan (易纂), Dayan lun
yijue (大衍論義決), Dayan xuantu (大衍玄圖), and
Dayan lun (大衍論). A text entitled Zixia Yi zhuan
exists, but it is unclear how it relates to what Yixing
compiled. The Jiu Tang shu (191.5112) cites the Dayan
lun as one of his works, perhaps indicating its contemporary significance.
The Xin Tang shu (27a.587) reports that Yixing
died in 727, while his calendar was in draft form.
The court ordered Zhang Yue (張說; 667–730) and
Chen Xuanjing (陳玄景; d.u.) to edit it. The Dayan li
came into official use from 729 until 762; its system
is explained in fasc. 34 of the Jiu Tang shu and fasc.
27–28 of the Xin Tang shu. Yixing’s work was later
criticized by the court astronomer Gautama Zhuan
(瞿曇譔; 712–776) who, in 733, together with Chen
Xuanjing reported to the court that the Dayan li had
plagiarized the *Navagraha (Jiuzhi li [九執曆]), a
work on Indian mathematical astronomy translated
in 718 by his father Gautama Siddhārtha (瞿曇悉
達; fl. c. 718). An investigation, however, concluded
these allegations were false, though modern scholarship suggests Yixing in fact had probably studied
some foreign science (Sen, 1995, 202–203).
In addition to his work on the state calendar,
Yixing also reformed the native Chinese system of
“field allocation” astrology (fenye [分野]), which
assigns segments of the sky to ancient territories
of China, establishing astral-terrestrial correspondences from which predictions are made primarily with respect to state concerns. This stands in
contrast to Indian and Iranian systems of astrology,
which focus on the fate of the individual. As the territory of China had expanded since ancient times, it
became necessary to account for these new lands,
and Yixing had a role in updating the system (Pankenier, 2013, 278–279).
Yixing wrote on the history of astronomy. The
Jiu Tang shu (191.5113) reports that when Zhang
Taisu (張太素) had compiled the Hou Wei shu (後
魏書, not extant), a history of the Wei dynasty, the
chapter on astronomy (Tianwen zhi [天文志]) was
incomplete and that Yixing finished it.
The Fantian huoluo jiuyao (梵天火羅九曜; T. 1311),
an astrology manual complete with mantras and a
Daoist rite for the Big Dipper, is attributed to teachings passed down (xiushu [修述]) from Yixing, but
this work contains Sogdian loanwords and Iranian
icons quite different from the Indian icons found
For use by the Author only | © 2019 Koninklijke Brill NV
804
Yixing
in the Garbhadhātu maṇḍala – the maṇḍala of
the Mahāvairocana-sūtra – with which he would
have been familiar (Taizō zuzō 胎藏圖象, T. 2978
[LXXXVII] 277–279)). Remarks in the preface and
colophon suggest a date of around 874, which
would make the attribution to Yixing anachronistic,
although Mollier (2008, 141) accepts the traditional
attribution to Yixing. The Beidou qixing humo fa
(北斗七星護摩法; T. 1310) and Xiuyao yigui (宿
曜儀軌; T. 1304) are also attributed to Yixing. Lü
Jianfu (2009, 347–349) identifies anachronistic
elements in the latter that indicate a composition
date from well after →Amoghavajra. Osabe (1963,
256–261) also expressed his doubts, suggesting
these works are specimens of popularized Esoteric
Buddhism. The Kanming yizhang jin (看命一掌金;
X. 1043), a divination manual edited in the Ming
period with Buddhist themes and comprised primarily of Chinese elements, is also attributed to
Yixing.
The Legendary Yixing
Yixing’s eminent status led to legendary stories. The
Japanese accounts state that when Yixing’s mother
was pregnant with him, she had a halo of white light
on her forehead. After giving birth, the halo moved
to the forehead of the child (Shingon fuhō den, 63
and Naishō buppō sōshō kechimyakufu, 239). Tales of
Yixing as an extraordinary monk are also found in
late Tang literature, demonstrating that his popular image extended outside Buddhism. The Kaitian
chuanxin ji (開天傳信記) of Zheng Qi (鄭綮; d. 899)
includes a story about the ghost of Yixing visiting
Puji (1042.845–846). Yixing is referred to by the title
“Heavenly Master” (tianshi [天師]), often used for
Daoist adepts. This story also appears in the Minghuang zalu buyi (明皇雜録補遺; 1035.523), compiled
in 855 by Zheng Chuhui (鄭處晦; d.u.), and the Youyang zazu (酉陽雜俎), compiled by Duan Chengshi
(段成式; d. 863) in 860 (1047.677).
The Jiu Tang shu (191.5112) reports that Yixing
met with an erudite Daoist adept named Yin Chong
(尹崇; d.u.) and borrowed from him the Taixuan
jing (太玄經) by Yang Xiong (揚雄; 53 BCE–18 CE),
an ancient divination manual. He returned home
with the book and after several days revisited Yin
Chong. Yin Chong admitted that the work was
profound and that after many years of investigation
he still was unable to entirely understand it. Yixing
stated that he had mastered its teachings and subsequently produced two works – the Dayan xuantu
(大衍玄圖) and Yijue (義決) – to show to an astonished Yin Chong. Yixing was declared to be a “later
born Yanzi” (i.e. Yan Hui 顏回, the foremost disciple
of Confucius known for his intelligence). Yixing
apparently acquired fame for himself as a result
of this, but the veracity of such a laudatory story is
doubtful and is likely a fictional account designed
to elevate the status of Yixing’s works on the Yijing.
Another tale relating Yixing’s intellectual prowess
is told in the Jiu Tang shu (191.5113), explaining that
Yixing ended up at Guoqing si (國清寺) on Mount
Tiantai (天台山) after a long search for instruction in the number theory of the Yijing (dayan [大
衍]). Yixing stood outside the gate and from inside
heard mathematical calculations being performed.
A monk inside told his disciple, “Today there should
be a disciple coming from afar in search of my arithmetic. I reckon he has arrived at the gate. Isn’t there
someone to let him in?” He then got out an abacus
and again said to his attendant, “The disciple will
arrive when the waters in front of the gate turn back
and flow westward.” Yixing requested teachings and
was subsequently fully instructed in the technique.
Sure enough, the water outside the gate then turned
back and flowed westward. This account appears to
stem from Yixing’s work with the Yijing rather than
Buddhist concerns. This same story with minor
variations is also told in the Song Gaoseng zhuan
(T. 2061 [L] 732c26–733a5), although it states Yixing
was in search of arithmetic (suanshu [算術]).
Foreign astrology was increasingly popularized
in China in the early 9th century, a development
which is reflected in literary and art records as
Indian and Iranian elements were absorbed into
the new systems of astrology in China. In tandem
with these developments, an associated practice of
astral magic was integrated into Buddhism and Daoism (Kotyk, 2016, 2017). Astral magic in the late Tang
conceived of the planets and nakṣatras as sentient
deities who could be appeased or deceived. In this
environment, a legendary image of Yixing emerged
as not only an adept astrologer but also as a sorcerer
capable of summoning stellar deities. One major
example of this is in the Qiyao xingchen bie xingfa
(七曜星辰別行法; T. 1309). It relates a story of Yixing
accompanying the Emperor Xuanzong on campaign
and carrying out a rite to bring down the spirits presiding over the stars. Yixing makes inquiries to the
gods of the 28 lunar stations (nakṣatra) and learns
of the 30 spirits who preside over illnesses (T. 1309
For use by the Author only | © 2019 Koninklijke Brill NV
Yixing
[XXI] 452c5–14). Astral knowledge attributed to
divine revelation is also a feature of Indian jyotiṣa
literature such as the Sūryasiddhānta. This fictional
account of Yixing is clearly the union of his historical roles in Mantrayāna and astronomy.
Bibliography
Chen, Jinhua, 2000–2001. “The Birth of a Polymath: The
Genealogical Background of the Tang Monk-Scientist
Yixing (673–727),” TSt 18–19, 1–39.
Dengyō Daishi zenshū (傳教大師全集), 1926. 5 vols., Sakamoto: Hieizan Senshūin Fuzoku Eizan Gakuin (比叡山
専修院附属叡山學院).
Dong Hao (董浩), 1983. Quan Tang wen (全唐文), Beijing:
Zhonghua Shuju.
Du You (杜佑), 1935. Tongdian (通 典), Taipei: Taiwan
Shangwu Yinshuguan; repr. 1987.
Duan Chengshi (段成式), 1983. Youyang zazu (酉陽雜
俎), in: Ying yin Wen yuan ge Si ku quan shu (景印文
淵閣四庫全書), vol. MXLVII, Taipei: Taiwan Shangwu
Yinshuguan, 637–835.
Endō Jun’ichirō (遠藤純一郎), 2007. “Dainichikyōsho ni
mirareru kegon-teki yōso ni tsuite” (『大日經疏』に
見られる華厳的要素について), CG 56, 461–492.
Kameyama Takahiko (亀山隆彦), 2007. “Dainichikyōsho
ni okeru senryakushaku shinpishaku ni tsuite” (『大
日経疏』における浅略釈・深秘釈について), IBK
56/1, 169–172.
Katō Seiichi (加藤精一), 1979. “Dainichikyōsho to Daichidoron” (『大日経疏』と『大智度論』), IBK 27/2,
735–738.
Kawamura Kōshō (河村孝照), 1959. “Dainichikyō sho
Gishaku taishō kō” (大日經疏義釋對照考), IBK 7/2,
553–554.
Keyworth, G.A., 2011. “Yixing,” in: C.D. Orzech, H. Sørensen
& R.K. Payne, eds., Esoteric Buddhism and the Tantras of
East Asia, Leiden: Brill, 342–344.
Kōbō Daishi zenshū (弘法大師全集), 1911. Tokyo: Yoshikawa Kōbunkan.
Kotyk, J., 2017. “Iranian Elements in Late-Tang Buddhist
Astrology,” AM 30/1, 25–58.
Kotyk, J., 2016. “Kanjiken no bungaku ni okeru saihōsenseijutsu no yōso: tōzai bunka kōryū ni okeru Bukkyō
no yakuwari” (漢字圏の文学における西方占星術の
要素:東西文化交流における仏教の役割), Bukkyō
bungaku kenkyū (佛教文學研究) 19, 85–110.
Liu Su (劉肅), 1983. “Tang xinyu” (唐新語), in: Ying yin
Wen yuan ge Si ku quan shu (景印文淵閣四庫全書),
vol. MXXXV, Taipei: Taiwan Shangwu Yinshuguan,
287–402.
Liu Xu (劉昫), 1975. Jiu Tang shu (舊唐書), Beijing:
Zhonghua Shuju.
Lü Jianfu (呂建福), 2009. Mijiao lunkao (密教論考),
Taipei: Kongting Shuyuan.
805
Lü Jianfu (呂建福), 1995. Zhongguo mijiao shi (中国密教
史), Beijing: Zhongguo Shehui Kexue Chubanshe.
Mano Shinya (真野 新也), 2015. “Kan’yaku Dainichikyō no
chūshakusho seiritsu ni kansuru ichi, ni no mondai”
(漢訳『大日経』の註釈書成立に関する一、二の
問題), IBK 64/1, 218–223.
Mollier, C., 2008. Buddhism and Taoism Face to Face: Scripture, Ritual, and Iconographic Exchange in Medieval
China, Honolulu: University of Hawai‘i Press.
Needham, J. & Wang Ling, 1959. Science and Civilisation
in China, vol. III: Mathematics and the Sciences of the
Heavens and the Earth, Cambridge UK: Cambridge University Press.
Ohashi, Yukio, 2011. “Astronomy and Mathematics of
Yixing,” in: Tsuko Nakamura, W. Orchiston, M. Soma &
R. Strom, eds., Mapping the Oriental Sky: Proceedings
of the Seventh International Conference on Oriental Astronomy, Tokyo: National Astronomical Observatory of
Japan, 171–178.
Osabe Kazuo (長部和雄), 1963. Ichigyō zenji no kenkyū
(一行禪師の研究), Kobe: Kōbe Shōka Daigaku Keizai
Kenkyūsho.
Osabe Kazuo (長部和雄), 1954. “Dainichikyō no sensha
to gishaku no saijisha ni kansuru gimon” (大日経疏の
撰者と義釈の再治者に関する疑問), MBu 27, 40–47.
Ouyang Xiu (歐陽修) & Song Qi (宋祁), 1975. Xin Tang
shu (新唐書), Beijing: Zhonghua Shuju.
Pankenier, D.W., 2013. Astrology and Cosmology in Early
China: Conforming Earth to Heaven, Cambridge UK:
Cambridge University Press.
Sen, T., 1995. “Gautama Zhuan: An Indian Astronomer at
the Tang Court,” China Report: A Journal of East Asian
Studies, 31/2, 197–208.
Shi Shuqing (史树青), 1976. “Ribenguo shouzang de Tangdai Yixing deng renhuaxiang” (日本国收藏的唐代一
行等人画像), Wenwu (文物) 3, 31–36.
Shimizu Akisumi (清水明澄), 2008. “Tōdo ni okeru
Dainichikyō chūshakusho no seiritsu katei: Onko jo
wo chūshin toshite” (唐土における『大日経』注釈
書の成立過程:『温古序』を中心として), MBu 221,
49–72.
Yabuuchi Kiyoshi (藪內清), 1944. Zuitō rekihō shi no
kenkyū (隋唐曆法史の硏究), Kyoto: Rinsen Shoten;
repr. 1989.
Yamamoto Shōichirō (山本匠一郎), 2012. “Dainichikyō no
shiryō to kenkyūshi gaikan” (『大日経』の資料と研
究史概観), GM 23, 73–102.
Zheng Chuhui (鄭處晦), 1983. Minghuang zalu buyi (明皇
雜録補遺), in: Ying yin Wen yuan ge Si ku quan shu
(景印文淵閣四庫全書), vol. MXXXV, Taipei: Taiwan
Shangwu Yinshuguan, 520–525.
Zheng Qi (鄭綮), 1983. “Kaitian chuanxin ji” (開天傳信
記), in: Ying yin Wen yuan ge Si ku quan shu (景印文
淵閣四庫全書), vol. MXLII, Taipei: Taiwan Shangwu
Yinshuguan, 839–848.
For use by the Author only | © 2019 Koninklijke Brill NV
Jeffrey Kotyk