Difference between revisions of "Bhavaviveka"
| (3 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
[[Image:Bhavaviveka.JPG|frame|Bhāvaviveka]] [[File:11d5e 0c5.jpg|thumb|250px|]] | [[Image:Bhavaviveka.JPG|frame|Bhāvaviveka]] [[File:11d5e 0c5.jpg|thumb|250px|]] | ||
| − | '''[[Bhāvaviveka]]''' (Tib. {{BigTibetan|[[ལེགས་ལྡན་འབྱེད་]]}}, [[Wyl.]] ''[[legs ldan 'byed]]''), aka '''[[Bhāviveka]]''' ({{BigTibetan|[[སྣང་བྲལ་]]}}, ''[[snang bral]]'') or '''[[Bhavya]]''' ({{BigTibetan|[[སྐལ་ལྡན]]}}, ''[[skal ldan]]'') (c.500-570), was a sixth century [[master]] of the [[Svatantrika]] school of [[Madhyamika]]. He was critical of [[Buddhapalita]]’s interpretation of [[Nagarjuna]]’s classic work ''[[The Root Verses on the Wisdom of the Middle Way]]'', because he believed [[Buddhapalita]] should have put forward {{Wiki|independent}} [[logical]] arguments, rather than simply pointing out the flaws in others’ positions. The [[great master]] [[Chandrakirti]] later defended [[Buddhapalita’s]] approach and sought to refute [[Bhavaviveka]]. [[Bhavaviveka]]: One of the “[[seventeen great panditas]]” and early expositor of the [[Svatantrika]] [[Madhyamaka]]. | + | '''[[Bhāvaviveka]]''' (Tib. {{BigTibetan|[[ལེགས་ལྡན་འབྱེད་]]}}, [[Wyl.]] ''[[legs ldan 'byed]]''), aka '''[[Bhāviveka]]''' ({{BigTibetan|[[སྣང་བྲལ་]]}}, ''[[snang bral]]'') or '''[[Bhavya]]''' ({{BigTibetan|[[སྐལ་ལྡན]]}}, ''[[skal ldan]]'') (c.500-570), was a sixth century [[master]] of the [[Svatantrika]] school of [[Madhyamika]]. |
| + | |||
| + | He was critical of [[Buddhapalita]]’s [[interpretation]] of [[Nagarjuna]]’s classic work ''[[The Root Verses on the Wisdom of the Middle Way]]'', because he believed [[Buddhapalita]] should have put forward {{Wiki|independent}} [[logical]] arguments, rather than simply pointing out the flaws in others’ positions. | ||
| + | |||
| + | The [[great master]] [[Chandrakirti]] later defended [[Buddhapalita’s]] approach and sought to refute [[Bhavaviveka]]. [[Bhavaviveka]]: One of the “[[seventeen great panditas]]” and early [[expositor]] of the [[Svatantrika]] [[Madhyamaka]]. | ||
==Writings== | ==Writings== | ||
| + | |||
*''[[Heart of the Middle Way]]'' and its auto-commentary, ''[[Blaze of Reason]]'' (Skt. ''[[Tarkajvāla]]'') | *''[[Heart of the Middle Way]]'' and its auto-commentary, ''[[Blaze of Reason]]'' (Skt. ''[[Tarkajvāla]]'') | ||
* ''[[Madhyamakārtha saṁgarha]]'' | * ''[[Madhyamakārtha saṁgarha]]'' | ||
| Line 8: | Line 13: | ||
==Quotations== | ==Quotations== | ||
| − | {{tibquote| | + | |
| − | + | {{tibquote|ཡང་དག་ཀུན་རྫོབ་རྣམས་ཀྱི་སྐས། །<br /> | |
| − | + | མེད་པར་ཡང་དག་ཁང་ཆེན་གྱི། །<br /> | |
| − | + | སྟེང་དུ་འགྲོ་བར་བྱ་བ་ནི། །<br /> | |
| + | མཁས་ལ་རུང་བ་མ་ཡིན་ནོ། །<br />}} | ||
Trying to reach the great mansion<br /> | Trying to reach the great mansion<br /> | ||
| − | Of the authentic nature of reality<br /> | + | Of the [[Wikipedia:Authenticity|authentic]] [[nature of reality]]<br /> |
| − | Without the steps of the authentic relative<br /> | + | Without the steps of the [[Wikipedia:Authenticity|authentic]] [[relative]]<br /> |
| − | Is not an approach the wise should take.<ref>This verse is also found in [[Atisha|Atīśa’s]] ''Introduction to the Two Truths'' (བདེན་གཉིས་ལ་འཇུག་པ་)</ref><br /> | + | Is not an approach the [[wise]] should take.<ref>This verse is also found in [[Atisha|Atīśa’s]] ''Introduction to the [[Two Truths]]'' ({{BigTibetan|བདེན་གཉིས་ལ་འཇུག་པ་}})</ref><br /> |
:::''[[Bhavaviveka|Bhāvaviveka]]'', ''[[Heart of the Middle Way]]'', III, 12 | :::''[[Bhavaviveka|Bhāvaviveka]]'', ''[[Heart of the Middle Way]]'', III, 12 | ||
| Line 23: | Line 29: | ||
{{Nolinking|*David Seyfort Ruegg, ''The {{Wiki|Literature}} of the [[Madhyamaka School]] of [[Philosophy]] in [[India]]'', Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz, 1981 | {{Nolinking|*David Seyfort Ruegg, ''The {{Wiki|Literature}} of the [[Madhyamaka School]] of [[Philosophy]] in [[India]]'', Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz, 1981 | ||
| − | *David Seyfort Ruegg, 'On the Authorship of Some Works Ascribed to Bhā(va)viveka/Bhavya' in ''The [[Buddhist Philosophy]] of the Middle'', Boston: [[Wisdom Publications]], 2010 | + | *[[David Seyfort Ruegg]], 'On the Authorship of Some Works Ascribed to Bhā(va)viveka/Bhavya' in ''The [[Buddhist Philosophy]] of the Middle'', Boston: [[Wisdom Publications]], 2010 |
| − | *Lobsang N. Tsonawa, ''[[Indian]] [[Buddhist]] [[Pandits]] from The [[Jewel]] Garland of [[Buddhist]] History'', {{Wiki|Dharamsala}}: {{Wiki|Library of Tibetan Works and Archives}}, 1985.}}{{reflist}} | + | *[[Lobsang N. Tsonawa]], ''[[Indian]] [[Buddhist]] [[Pandits]] from The [[Jewel]] Garland of [[Buddhist]] History'', {{Wiki|Dharamsala}}: {{Wiki|Library of Tibetan Works and Archives}}, 1985.}}{{reflist}} |
{{RigpaWiki}} | {{RigpaWiki}} | ||
| Line 33: | Line 39: | ||
| − | Also known as [[Bhavya]]. An [[Indian]] [[Buddhist]] [[scholar]] of [[Madhyamika philosophy]]. He is the founder of the [[Svatantrika school]], one of the two schools of [[Madhyamika]], the other {{Wiki|being}} the [[Prasangika school]] led by his contemporary, [[Buddhapalita]]. Born to the {{Wiki|royal}} family in {{Wiki|Magadha}}, [[India]], [[Bhavaviveka]] studied the [[Mahayana sutras]] and [[Nagarjuna's]] works under [[Samgharakshita]], a [[Madhyamika]] [[scholar]]. Later, he wrote The [[Treatise on the Lamp of Wisdom]] (Skt [[Prajna-pradipa]] ), a commentary on [[Nagarjuna's]] [[Verses on the Middle Way]] ([[Madhyamaka-karika]]), in which he criticized [[Buddhapalita's]] method of demonstrating the [[truth]] of [[nonsubstantiality]]. As a result, the [[Madhyamika]] school split into two. To demonstrate the [[truth]] of [[nonsubstantiality]], [[Bhavaviveka]] adopted [[Dignaga's]] method of [[Buddhist logic]]. He wrote The [[Heart of the Middle Way]] ([[Madhyamaka-hridaya]] ) in which he criticized the [[doctrine]] of the [[Vijnanavada]], or [[Consciousness-Only]], school. [[Dharmapala]] of the [[Consciousness-Only school]] retorted [[Bhavaviveka's]] criticisms. [[Bhavaviveka]] took the position that all [[phenomena]] are [[interdependent]] and have no {{Wiki|independent}} [[existence]] of their own, or are [[non-substantial]] in {{Wiki|nature}}. [[Dharmapala]] asserted that [[phenomena]] arise from [[consciousness]] ([[vijnana]] ), which is the only [[reality]]. (The [[Sanskrit]] words [[madhyamika]] and [[madhyamaka]] both mean [[intermediate]] or [[middle]].) | + | Also known as [[Bhavya]]. An [[Indian]] [[Buddhist]] [[scholar]] of [[Madhyamika philosophy]]. |
| + | |||
| + | He is the founder of the [[Svatantrika school]], one of the two schools of [[Madhyamika]], the other {{Wiki|being}} the [[Prasangika school]] led by his contemporary, [[Buddhapalita]]. | ||
| + | |||
| + | Born to the {{Wiki|royal}} family in {{Wiki|Magadha}}, [[India]], [[Bhavaviveka]] studied the [[Mahayana sutras]] and [[Nagarjuna's]] works under [[Samgharakshita]], a [[Madhyamika]] [[scholar]]. Later, he wrote The [[Treatise on the Lamp of Wisdom]] (Skt [[Prajna-pradipa]] ), a commentary on [[Nagarjuna's]] [[Verses on the Middle Way]] ([[Madhyamaka-karika]]), in which he criticized [[Buddhapalita's]] method of demonstrating the [[truth]] of [[nonsubstantiality]]. As a result, the [[Madhyamika]] school split into two. | ||
| + | |||
| + | To demonstrate the [[truth]] of [[nonsubstantiality]], [[Bhavaviveka]] adopted [[Dignaga's]] method of [[Buddhist logic]]. | ||
| + | |||
| + | He wrote The [[Heart of the Middle Way]] ([[Madhyamaka-hridaya]] ) in which he criticized the [[doctrine]] of the [[Vijnanavada]], or [[Consciousness-Only]], school. [[Dharmapala]] of the [[Consciousness-Only school]] retorted [[Bhavaviveka's]] {{Wiki|criticisms}}. | ||
| + | |||
| + | [[Bhavaviveka]] took the position that all [[phenomena]] are [[interdependent]] and have no {{Wiki|independent}} [[existence]] of their [[own]], or are [[non-substantial]] in {{Wiki|nature}}. [[Dharmapala]] asserted that [[phenomena]] arise from [[consciousness]] ([[vijnana]] ), which is the only [[reality]]. (The [[Sanskrit]] words [[madhyamika]] and [[madhyamaka]] both mean [[intermediate]] or [[middle]].) | ||
{{R}} | {{R}} | ||
[http://www.sgilibrary.org/search_dict.php?id=157 www.sgilibrary.org] | [http://www.sgilibrary.org/search_dict.php?id=157 www.sgilibrary.org] | ||
Latest revision as of 00:19, 6 April 2015
Bhāvaviveka (Tib. ལེགས་ལྡན་འབྱེད་, Wyl. legs ldan 'byed), aka Bhāviveka (སྣང་བྲལ་, snang bral) or Bhavya (སྐལ་ལྡན, skal ldan) (c.500-570), was a sixth century master of the Svatantrika school of Madhyamika.
He was critical of Buddhapalita’s interpretation of Nagarjuna’s classic work The Root Verses on the Wisdom of the Middle Way, because he believed Buddhapalita should have put forward independent logical arguments, rather than simply pointing out the flaws in others’ positions.
The great master Chandrakirti later defended Buddhapalita’s approach and sought to refute Bhavaviveka. Bhavaviveka: One of the “seventeen great panditas” and early expositor of the Svatantrika Madhyamaka.
Writings
- Heart of the Middle Way and its auto-commentary, Blaze of Reason (Skt. Tarkajvāla)
- Madhyamakārtha saṁgarha
- Prajñāpradīpa
Quotations
མེད་པར་ཡང་དག་ཁང་ཆེན་གྱི། །
སྟེང་དུ་འགྲོ་བར་བྱ་བ་ནི། །
Trying to reach the great mansion
Of the authentic nature of reality
Without the steps of the authentic relative
Is not an approach the wise should take.[1]
- Bhāvaviveka, Heart of the Middle Way, III, 12
Further Reading
- David Seyfort Ruegg, The Literature of the Madhyamaka School of Philosophy in India, Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz, 1981
- David Seyfort Ruegg, 'On the Authorship of Some Works Ascribed to Bhā(va)viveka/Bhavya' in The Buddhist Philosophy of the Middle, Boston: Wisdom Publications, 2010
- Lobsang N. Tsonawa, Indian Buddhist Pandits from The Jewel Garland of Buddhist History, Dharamsala: Library of Tibetan Works and Archives, 1985.==Footnotes==
- ↑ This verse is also found in Atīśa’s Introduction to the Two Truths (བདེན་གཉིས་ལ་འཇུག་པ་)
Source
Bhavaviveka
清弁 (c. 490–570) (Skt; Jpn Shoben)
Also known as Bhavya. An Indian Buddhist scholar of Madhyamika philosophy.
He is the founder of the Svatantrika school, one of the two schools of Madhyamika, the other being the Prasangika school led by his contemporary, Buddhapalita.
Born to the royal family in Magadha, India, Bhavaviveka studied the Mahayana sutras and Nagarjuna's works under Samgharakshita, a Madhyamika scholar. Later, he wrote The Treatise on the Lamp of Wisdom (Skt Prajna-pradipa ), a commentary on Nagarjuna's Verses on the Middle Way (Madhyamaka-karika), in which he criticized Buddhapalita's method of demonstrating the truth of nonsubstantiality. As a result, the Madhyamika school split into two.
To demonstrate the truth of nonsubstantiality, Bhavaviveka adopted Dignaga's method of Buddhist logic.
He wrote The Heart of the Middle Way (Madhyamaka-hridaya ) in which he criticized the doctrine of the Vijnanavada, or Consciousness-Only, school. Dharmapala of the Consciousness-Only school retorted Bhavaviveka's criticisms.
Bhavaviveka took the position that all phenomena are interdependent and have no independent existence of their own, or are non-substantial in nature. Dharmapala asserted that phenomena arise from consciousness (vijnana ), which is the only reality. (The Sanskrit words madhyamika and madhyamaka both mean intermediate or middle.)
