Difference between revisions of "Māna"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
m (Text replacement - "Category:Pali terminology" to "{{PaliTerminology}}") |
|||
| Line 15: | Line 15: | ||
: There is [[conceit]] or {{Wiki|pride}} when we consider ourselves important. Because of [[conceit]] we may compare ourselves with others. There can be [[conceit]] when we think ourselves better, {{Wiki|equal}} or less than someone else. We may believe that there can be [[conceit]] only when we think ourselves better than someone else, but this is not so. There can be a kind of upholding of ourselves, of making ourselves important, while we compare ourselves with someone else, no {{Wiki|matter}} in what way, and that is [[conceit]]. | : There is [[conceit]] or {{Wiki|pride}} when we consider ourselves important. Because of [[conceit]] we may compare ourselves with others. There can be [[conceit]] when we think ourselves better, {{Wiki|equal}} or less than someone else. We may believe that there can be [[conceit]] only when we think ourselves better than someone else, but this is not so. There can be a kind of upholding of ourselves, of making ourselves important, while we compare ourselves with someone else, no {{Wiki|matter}} in what way, and that is [[conceit]]. | ||
| − | The [[Atthasālinī]] (II, Part IX, Chapter III, 256) gives the following [[definition]] of [[conceit]]: | + | The [[Atthasālinī]] (II, Part IX, [[Chapter]] III, 256) gives the following [[definition]] of [[conceit]]: |
: ...Herein [[conceit]] is fancying (deeming, vain [[imagining]]). It has haughtiness as [[characteristic]], self-praise as [[function]], [[desire]] to (advertise [[self]] like) a [[banner]] as [[manifestation]], [[greed]] dissociated from [[opinionatedness]] as proximate [[cause]], and should be regarded as (a [[form]] of) lunacy. | : ...Herein [[conceit]] is fancying (deeming, vain [[imagining]]). It has haughtiness as [[characteristic]], self-praise as [[function]], [[desire]] to (advertise [[self]] like) a [[banner]] as [[manifestation]], [[greed]] dissociated from [[opinionatedness]] as proximate [[cause]], and should be regarded as (a [[form]] of) lunacy. | ||
| Line 31: | Line 31: | ||
[[Alexander Berzin]] explains: | [[Alexander Berzin]] explains: | ||
| − | : [[Arrogance]] (nga-rgyal, {{Wiki|pride}}) is a puffed-up [[mind]] (khengs-pa) based on a deluded outlook toward a transitory network (‘jig-lta). [...] It functions to make us not appreciate others or [[respect]] the good qualities of others (mi-gus-pa) and to prevent us from {{Wiki|learning}} anything. | + | : [[Arrogance]] ([[nga-rgyal]], {{Wiki|pride}}) is a puffed-up [[mind]] (khengs-pa) based on a deluded outlook toward a transitory network (‘jig-lta). [...] It functions to make us not appreciate others or [[respect]] the good qualities of others (mi-gus-pa) and to prevent us from {{Wiki|learning}} anything. |
The [[Mahayana]] [[tradition]] identifies seven types of [[arrogance]]: | The [[Mahayana]] [[tradition]] identifies seven types of [[arrogance]]: | ||
| − | * [[Arrogance]] (nga-rgyal) is a puffed-up [[mind]] that [[feels]] one is better than someone who has {{Wiki|inferior}} qualities. | + | * [[Arrogance]] ([[nga-rgyal]]) is a puffed-up [[mind]] that [[feels]] one is better than someone who has {{Wiki|inferior}} qualities. |
| − | * Exaggerated [[arrogance]] (lhag-pa’i nga-rgyal) is a puffed-up [[mind]] that [[feels]] one is better than one's peers (someone {{Wiki|equal}} to oneself in some quality). | + | * Exaggerated [[arrogance]] (lhag-pa’i [[nga-rgyal]]) is a puffed-up [[mind]] that [[feels]] one is better than one's peers (someone {{Wiki|equal}} to oneself in some quality). |
| − | * Outrageous [[arrogance]] (nga-rgyal-las-kyang nga-rgyal) is a puffed-up [[mind]] that [[feels]] one is better than someone {{Wiki|superior}} to oneself in some quality. | + | * Outrageous [[arrogance]] (nga-rgyal-las-kyang [[nga-rgyal]]) is a puffed-up [[mind]] that [[feels]] one is better than someone {{Wiki|superior}} to oneself in some quality. |
| − | * Egotistic [[arrogance]] (nga’o snyam-pa’i nga-rgyal) is a puffed-up [[mind]] that [[thinks]] “me” while focusing on our own [[Samsara]]-perpetuating [[aggregates]] (nyer-len-gyi phung-po). | + | * Egotistic [[arrogance]] (nga’o snyam-pa’i [[nga-rgyal]]) is a puffed-up [[mind]] that [[thinks]] “me” while focusing on our own [[Samsara]]-perpetuating [[aggregates]] (nyer-len-gyi phung-po). |
| − | * False or anticipatory [[arrogance]] or [[arrogance]] of showing off (mngon-par nga-rgyal) is a puffed-up [[mind]] that [[feels]] I have [[attained]] some quality that I have not actually [[attained]] or not yet [[attained]]; or [[thinking]] one has achievements when one has achieved [[nothing]]. | + | * False or anticipatory [[arrogance]] or [[arrogance]] of showing off (mngon-par [[nga-rgyal]]) is a puffed-up [[mind]] that [[feels]] I have [[attained]] some quality that I have not actually [[attained]] or not yet [[attained]]; or [[thinking]] one has achievements when one has achieved [[nothing]]. |
| − | * Modest [[arrogance]] or [[arrogance]] of [[thinking]] small (cung-zad snyam-pa’i nga-rgyal) is a puffed-up [[mind]] that [[feels]] that I am just a little bit {{Wiki|inferior}} compared to someone vastly {{Wiki|superior}} to myself in some quality, but still {{Wiki|superior}} to almost everyone else. | + | * Modest [[arrogance]] or [[arrogance]] of [[thinking]] small (cung-zad snyam-pa’i [[nga-rgyal]]) is a puffed-up [[mind]] that [[feels]] that I am just a little bit {{Wiki|inferior}} compared to someone vastly {{Wiki|superior}} to myself in some quality, but still {{Wiki|superior}} to almost everyone else. |
| − | * Distorted [[arrogance]] or perverted [[arrogance]] (log-pa’i nga-rgyal) is a puffed-up [[mind]] that [[feels]] that some deviant aspect that I have fallen to (khol-sar shor-ba) is a good quality that I have attained—for instance, [[being]] a good {{Wiki|hunter}}. | + | * Distorted [[arrogance]] or perverted [[arrogance]] (log-pa’i [[nga-rgyal]]) is a puffed-up [[mind]] that [[feels]] that some deviant aspect that I have fallen to (khol-sar shor-ba) is a good quality that I have attained—for instance, [[being]] a good {{Wiki|hunter}}. |
=From Palikanon.com= | =From Palikanon.com= | ||
'[[conceit]]', {{Wiki|pride}}, is one of the [[10 fetters]] binding to [[existence]] (s. [[samyojana]]). It vanishes completely only at the entrance to [[Arahatship]], or Holiness (cf. [[asmi-māna]]). It is further one of the proclivities (s. [[anusaya]]) and [[defilements]] (s. [[kilesa]]). " | '[[conceit]]', {{Wiki|pride}}, is one of the [[10 fetters]] binding to [[existence]] (s. [[samyojana]]). It vanishes completely only at the entrance to [[Arahatship]], or Holiness (cf. [[asmi-māna]]). It is further one of the proclivities (s. [[anusaya]]) and [[defilements]] (s. [[kilesa]]). " | ||
| − | The (equality-) [[conceit]] ([[māna]]), the inferiority-conceit (omāna) and the superiority-conceit ([[atimāna]]): this threefold [[conceit]] should be overcome. For, after [[overcoming]] this threefold [[conceit]], the [[monk]], through the full [[penetration]] of [[conceit]], is said to have put an end [[suffering]]" (A. VI, 49). | + | The (equality-) [[conceit]] ([[māna]]), the [[inferiority-conceit]] (omāna) and the [[superiority-conceit]] ([[atimāna]]): this threefold [[conceit]] should be overcome. For, after [[overcoming]] this threefold [[conceit]], the [[monk]], through the full [[penetration]] of [[conceit]], is said to have put an [[end]] [[suffering]]" (A. VI, 49). |
"Those [[ascetics]] and [[brahman]] {{Wiki|priests}} who, relying on this [[impermanent]], [[miserable]] and transitory [[nature]] of corporeality, [[feelings]], [[perceptions]], [[mental formations]] and [[consciousness]], fancy: 'Better am I', or '{{Wiki|Equal}} am I', or 'Worse am I', all these [[imagine]] thus through not [[understanding]] [[reality]]" (S. XXII, 49). | "Those [[ascetics]] and [[brahman]] {{Wiki|priests}} who, relying on this [[impermanent]], [[miserable]] and transitory [[nature]] of corporeality, [[feelings]], [[perceptions]], [[mental formations]] and [[consciousness]], fancy: 'Better am I', or '{{Wiki|Equal}} am I', or 'Worse am I', all these [[imagine]] thus through not [[understanding]] [[reality]]" (S. XXII, 49). | ||
Revision as of 02:23, 8 October 2014
Māna (Sanskrit, Pali; Tibetan: nga rgyal) is a Buddhist term that is translated as "pride", "arrogance", or "conceit". It is defined as an inflated mind that makes whatever is suitable, such as wealth or learning, to be the foundation of pride. It creates the basis for disrespecting others and for the occurrence of Suffering.
Māna is identified as:
- One of the five poisons within the Mahayana Buddhist tradition.
- One of the six root unwholesome mental factors within the Mahayana Abhidharma teachings
- One of the fourteen unwholesome mental factors within the Theravada Abhidharma teachings
- One of the ten fetters in the Theravada tradition
Explanations
Theravada
Nina van Gorkom explains:
- There is conceit or pride when we consider ourselves important. Because of conceit we may compare ourselves with others. There can be conceit when we think ourselves better, equal or less than someone else. We may believe that there can be conceit only when we think ourselves better than someone else, but this is not so. There can be a kind of upholding of ourselves, of making ourselves important, while we compare ourselves with someone else, no matter in what way, and that is conceit.
The Atthasālinī (II, Part IX, Chapter III, 256) gives the following definition of conceit:
- ...Herein conceit is fancying (deeming, vain imagining). It has haughtiness as characteristic, self-praise as function, desire to (advertise self like) a banner as manifestation, greed dissociated from opinionatedness as proximate cause, and should be regarded as (a form of) lunacy.
Mahayana
The Abhidharma-samuccaya states:
- What is arrogance? It is an inflated mind as to what is perishable and its function is to serve as the basis for disrespect and frustrations.
Herbert Guenther explains:
- Arrogance is a mental event which is a kind of inflated mind making whatever is suitable, such as wealth or learning, to be the foundation of pride.
Alexander Berzin explains:
- Arrogance (nga-rgyal, pride) is a puffed-up mind (khengs-pa) based on a deluded outlook toward a transitory network (‘jig-lta). [...] It functions to make us not appreciate others or respect the good qualities of others (mi-gus-pa) and to prevent us from learning anything.
The Mahayana tradition identifies seven types of arrogance:
- Arrogance (nga-rgyal) is a puffed-up mind that feels one is better than someone who has inferior qualities.
- Exaggerated arrogance (lhag-pa’i nga-rgyal) is a puffed-up mind that feels one is better than one's peers (someone equal to oneself in some quality).
- Outrageous arrogance (nga-rgyal-las-kyang nga-rgyal) is a puffed-up mind that feels one is better than someone superior to oneself in some quality.
- Egotistic arrogance (nga’o snyam-pa’i nga-rgyal) is a puffed-up mind that thinks “me” while focusing on our own Samsara-perpetuating aggregates (nyer-len-gyi phung-po).
- False or anticipatory arrogance or arrogance of showing off (mngon-par nga-rgyal) is a puffed-up mind that feels I have attained some quality that I have not actually attained or not yet attained; or thinking one has achievements when one has achieved nothing.
- Modest arrogance or arrogance of thinking small (cung-zad snyam-pa’i nga-rgyal) is a puffed-up mind that feels that I am just a little bit inferior compared to someone vastly superior to myself in some quality, but still superior to almost everyone else.
- Distorted arrogance or perverted arrogance (log-pa’i nga-rgyal) is a puffed-up mind that feels that some deviant aspect that I have fallen to (khol-sar shor-ba) is a good quality that I have attained—for instance, being a good hunter.
From Palikanon.com
'conceit', pride, is one of the 10 fetters binding to existence (s. samyojana). It vanishes completely only at the entrance to Arahatship, or Holiness (cf. asmi-māna). It is further one of the proclivities (s. anusaya) and defilements (s. kilesa). "
The (equality-) conceit (māna), the inferiority-conceit (omāna) and the superiority-conceit (atimāna): this threefold conceit should be overcome. For, after overcoming this threefold conceit, the monk, through the full penetration of conceit, is said to have put an end suffering" (A. VI, 49).
"Those ascetics and brahman priests who, relying on this impermanent, miserable and transitory nature of corporeality, feelings, perceptions, mental formations and consciousness, fancy: 'Better am I', or 'Equal am I', or 'Worse am I', all these imagine thus through not understanding reality" (S. XXII, 49).
In reality no ego-entity is to be found. Cf. anattā.
