Difference between revisions of "Jigten Sumgön’s Teaching of Bodhicitta"
Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
− | This year, I have published much less on this blog because I have been very busy with a wonderful project at a Consortium of the University of Erlangen-Nürnberg called | + | This year, I have published much less on this blog because I have been very busy with a wonderful project at a Consortium of the {{Wiki|University}} of Erlangen-Nürnberg called “[[Fate]], Freedom and Prognostication: Strategies for Coping with the Future in {{Wiki|East Asia}} and {{Wiki|Europe}}.” |
− | In this project, I have studied Central and East Asian divination texts and worked together with Solvej Hyveled Nielsen on a dice divination text of Achi Chökyi Dölma. | + | In this project, I have studied Central and {{Wiki|East Asian}} {{Wiki|divination}} texts and worked together with Solvej Hyveled Nielsen on a dice {{Wiki|divination}} text of [[Achi]] Chökyi [[Dölma]]. |
− | Solvej has also contributed a translation of a mala divination text of Tara that is ascribed to Atisha. | + | Solvej has also contributed a translation of a [[mala]] {{Wiki|divination}} text of [[Tara]] that is ascribed to [[Atisha]]. |
− | We hope that we will soon be able to present our book Divining with Achi and Tara, which will include a comparative study of dice divination, detailed interviews with Khenchen Nyima Gyaltsen Rinpoche and Lho Ontul Rinpoche, appendices on the specialised Tibetan terminology of divination and more. | + | We {{Wiki|hope}} that we will soon be able to {{Wiki|present}} our [[book]] Divining with [[Achi]] and [[Tara]], which will include a comparative study of dice {{Wiki|divination}}, detailed interviews with [[Khenchen]] [[Nyima]] [[Gyaltsen Rinpoche]] and Lho Ontul [[Rinpoche]], appendices on the specialised [[Tibetan]] {{Wiki|terminology}} of {{Wiki|divination}} and more. |
− | This blog will now undergo a small transformation. | + | This blog will now undergo a small [[transformation]]. |
− | Instead of being solely devoted to Jigten Sumgön’s | + | Instead of being solely devoted to [[Jigten Sumgön’s]] “[[Single Intention]]” (dGongs gcig), it will from now on be concerned with his teachings in general. |
− | I will, therefore, soon migrate a few articles from my other blog, “The World of Jigten Sumgön,” to this blog. | + | I will, therefore, soon migrate a few articles from my other blog, “The [[World]] of [[Jigten Sumgön]],” to this blog. |
− | In truth, whichever teaching of Jigten Sumgön we study, we will find that it always reflects the central idea that the teachings of all Buddhas have only one single intention. | + | In [[truth]], whichever [[teaching]] of [[Jigten Sumgön]] we study, we will find that it always reflects the central [[idea]] that the teachings of all [[Buddhas]] have only one [[single intention]]. |
− | The blog entry of today is concerned with Jigten Sumgön’s teaching of the two resolves for awakening (bodhicitta). | + | The blog entry of today is concerned with [[Jigten Sumgön’s]] [[teaching]] of the two resolves for [[awakening]] ([[bodhicitta]]). |
− | In agreement with the idea of the unity of all teachings, he maintains that the “two | + | In agreement with the [[idea]] of the {{Wiki|unity}} of all teachings, he maintains that the “two [[bodhicittas]]” are actually “of a single {{Wiki|taste}} like sesame and sesame oil.” |
− | Moreover, ultimately speaking, bodhicitta is not different from the absolute nature of reality, or Buddha nature, which is also the thing to be dedicated. | + | Moreover, ultimately {{Wiki|speaking}}, [[bodhicitta]] is not different from the [[absolute nature of reality]], or [[Buddha nature]], which is also the thing to be dedicated. |
− | The teaching is brief but very profound. | + | The [[teaching]] is brief but very profound. |
− | Bestowing the pith instructions of cultivating the two resolves for awakening on [[Yeshe Tseg]] | + | Bestowing the [[pith instructions]] of [[cultivating]] the two resolves for [[awakening]] on [[Yeshe Tseg]] |
Om swasti! | Om swasti! | ||
− | Respectfully I pay homage with my body to the feet of glorious [[Phagmodrupa]], protector of the three worlds, and essence of the gnosis of body, speech, and mind of the Buddhas of the three times. | + | Respectfully I pay homage with my [[body]] to the feet of glorious [[Phagmodrupa]], [[protector]] of the [[three worlds]], and [[essence]] of the [[gnosis]] of [[body]], {{Wiki|speech}}, and [[mind]] of the [[Buddhas of the three times]]. |
− | With a pure mind, I take refuge. | + | With a [[pure mind]], I [[take refuge]]. |
− | In general, to achieve supreme, completely awakened Buddhahood, there is nothing but the resolve for awakening whereby complete awakening can be obtained. If [the resolve] is lacking, that is a certain cause [for awakening] not to arise. | + | In general, to achieve supreme, completely [[awakened]] [[Buddhahood]], there is nothing but the resolve for [[awakening]] whereby complete [[awakening]] can be obtained. If [the resolve] is lacking, that is a certain [[cause]] [for [[awakening]]] not to arise. |
− | This resolve for awakening has two aspects. | + | This resolve for [[awakening]] has two aspects. |
− | From the point of view of cultivating the conventional resolve for awakening, when you engage in the cultivation of the root of immeasurably vast virtue – or, respectively, in the first morning session – you bless the three longer and shorter periods of time, thinking from the depth of your heart and the marrow of your bones: | + | From the point of view of [[cultivating]] the [[Wikipedia:Convention (norm)|conventional]] resolve for [[awakening]], when you engage in the [[cultivation]] of the [[root]] of immeasurably vast [[virtue]] – or, respectively, in the first morning session – you bless the three longer and shorter periods of time, [[thinking]] from the depth of your [[heart]] and the marrow of your [[bones]]: |
− | May all sentient beings – my mothers who are as infinite as space – have happiness, be free from suffering, and obtain the precious, supreme, and complete awakening. | + | May all [[sentient beings]] – my mothers who are as [[infinite]] as [[space]] – have [[happiness]], be free from [[suffering]], and obtain the [[precious]], supreme, and complete [[awakening]]. |
− | To achieve that, I will bind body, speech, and mind to virtue until I have obtained Buddhahood, I will bind body, speech, and mind to virtue until I die, and I will bind body, speech, and mind to virtue from today until tomorrow. | + | To achieve that, I will bind [[body]], {{Wiki|speech}}, and [[mind]] to [[virtue]] until I have obtained [[Buddhahood]], I will bind [[body]], {{Wiki|speech}}, and [[mind]] to [[virtue]] until I [[die]], and I will bind [[body]], {{Wiki|speech}}, and [[mind]] to [[virtue]] from today until tomorrow. |
− | Then, for the practice, you should train all the roots of virtue of body, speech, and mind in terms of that intention. | + | Then, for the practice, you should train all the [[roots of virtue]] of [[body]], {{Wiki|speech}}, and [[mind]] in terms of that [[intention]]. |
− | Moreover, having cultivated the resolve for awakening in the morning or when you are at ease to do so, you must take the roots of virtue of | + | Moreover, having cultivated the resolve for [[awakening]] in the morning or when you are at ease to do so, you must take the [[roots of virtue]] of |
− | body, speech, and mind that implement that [intention] as an example and dedicate the virtue that is accumulated by you and all others in | + | [[body]], {{Wiki|speech}}, and [[mind]] that implement that [[[intention]]] as an example and dedicate the [[virtue]] that is [[accumulated]] by you and all others in |
− | the three times and the root of the virtue of true reality to complete awakening. That is the conventional resolve for awakening, the | + | the three times and the [[root]] of the [[virtue]] of [[true reality]] to complete [[awakening]]. That is the [[Wikipedia:Convention (norm)|conventional]] resolve for [[awakening]], the |
− | intention of all masters of skill – the Buddhas of the three times – and the great treasure that will accomplish all temporary and ultimate | + | [[intention]] of all [[masters]] of skill – the [[Buddhas of the three times]] – and the great [[treasure]] that will accomplish all temporary and [[Wikipedia:Absolute (philosophy)|ultimate]] |
− | qualities. Therefore, you should cultivate the conventional resolve for awakening. | + | qualities. Therefore, you should cultivate the [[Wikipedia:Convention (norm)|conventional]] resolve for [[awakening]]. |
− | Now, how is the ultimate resolve for awakening practised? | + | Now, how is the [[Wikipedia:Absolute (philosophy)|ultimate]] resolve for [[awakening]] practised? |
− | The ultimate resolve for awakening is exactly that same conventional resolve for awakening, but free from the extremes of all proliferations of arising, ceasing, and abiding, the true reality. | + | The [[Wikipedia:Absolute (philosophy)|ultimate]] resolve for [[awakening]] is exactly that same [[Wikipedia:Convention (norm)|conventional]] resolve for [[awakening]], but free from the extremes of all proliferations of [[arising]], ceasing, and abiding, the [[true reality]]. |
− | Similarly, Acarya Arya [Nagarjuna], too, says: | + | Similarly, [[Acarya]] [[Arya]] [[[Nagarjuna]]], too, says: |
Line 90: | Line 90: | ||
[[Samsara]] and [[nirvana]] are not two. | [[Samsara]] and [[nirvana]] are not two. | ||
− | Understanding the nature of [[samsara]] is called nirvana. | + | [[Understanding]] the [[nature]] of [[samsara]] is called [[nirvana]]. |
− | And the precious guru [[Phagmodrupa]], too, says: | + | And the [[precious guru]] [[Phagmodrupa]], too, says: |
− | Complete pacification of proliferation is the absolute resolve for awakening. | + | Complete pacification of {{Wiki|proliferation}} is the [[absolute]] resolve for [[awakening]]. |
− | [That and] conventional preliminary resolve and its actualization thoroughly moistened with compassion are of a single taste like sesame and sesame oil. | + | [That and] [[Wikipedia:Convention (norm)|conventional]] preliminary resolve and its actualization thoroughly moistened with [[compassion]] are of a single {{Wiki|taste}} like sesame and sesame oil. |
− | Therefore, [relative and absolute resolve] are to be known as inseparable. | + | Therefore, [[[relative]] and [[absolute]] resolve] are to be known as [[inseparable]]. |
− | And with that regard, even though there are systems of practicing [the absolute] as an emptiness where all things are discerned by way of | + | And with that regard, even though there are systems of practicing [the [[absolute]]] as an [[emptiness]] where all things are discerned by way of |
− | atoms and divisions of parts of atoms, we maintain that it is realised only by way of devotion to the excellent guru, since that is what has | + | [[atoms]] and divisions of parts of [[atoms]], we maintain that it is realised only by way of [[devotion]] to the {{Wiki|excellent}} [[guru]], since that is what has |
− | been maintained by our precious guru [Phagmodrupa]. Similarly, the Exalted One has taught it in the Shri Hevajra Tantra: | + | been maintained by our [[precious guru]] [[[Phagmodrupa]]]. Similarly, the [[Exalted One]] has [[taught]] it in the [[Shri Hevajra]] [[Tantra]]: |
Line 118: | Line 118: | ||
which one cannot find anywhere, | which one cannot find anywhere, | ||
− | one must know through the ultimate guru sacrifice | + | one must know through the [[Wikipedia:Absolute (philosophy)|ultimate]] [[guru]] [[Wikipedia:sacrifice|sacrifice]] |
− | and through one’s merit. | + | and through one’s [[merit]]. |
− | Therefore, we assert the essence of the nature of the mind to be without interruption when the meaning that is beyond expression and thought | + | Therefore, we assert the [[essence]] of the [[nature of the mind]] to be without interruption when the meaning that is beyond expression and [[thought]] |
− | and that is not the object of theoreticians – the inborn gnosis that is free from proliferation – has arisen as something that arises | + | and that is not the [[object]] of theoreticians – the inborn [[gnosis]] that is free from {{Wiki|proliferation}} – has arisen as something that arises |
− | naturally through the devotion to the excellent guru and by the gathering of the accumulation of merit that precedes that. | + | naturally through the [[devotion]] to the {{Wiki|excellent}} [[guru]] and by the [[gathering]] of the [[accumulation of merit]] that precedes that. |
− | How is that practised? First, sit well on a comfortable seat in the cross-legged position and remain with the five limbs of concentration. | + | How is that practised? First, sit well on a comfortable seat in the cross-legged position and remain with the [[five limbs]] of [[concentration]]. |
− | Then, first, cultivate the resolve for supreme awakening and cultivate the body as the deity of Mantra. | + | Then, first, cultivate the resolve for supreme [[awakening]] and cultivate the [[body]] as the [[deity]] of [[Mantra]]. |
− | Then, meditate the excellent guru on the top of your head or in your heart and remain in a state of an unfabricated mind. | + | Then, [[meditate]] the {{Wiki|excellent}} [[guru]] on the top of your head or in your [[heart]] and remain in a [[state]] of an unfabricated [[mind]]. |
− | Do not grasp [the mind] as existing – that would be eternalism. | + | Do not [[grasp]] [the [[mind]]] as [[existing]] – that would be {{Wiki|eternalism}}. |
− | Do not meditate it as non-existent – that would be annihilism. | + | Do not [[meditate]] it as [[non-existent]] – that would be annihilism. |
− | Do not meditate it “without | + | Do not [[meditate]] it “without [[grasping]]” – that would be “[[fabricated]] by the [[mind]].” |
− | Leave [the mind] fresh, unfabricated, and unbound. | + | Leave [the [[mind]]] fresh, unfabricated, and unbound. |
− | From making supplications [to the guru in this state] and habituating [to that], | + | From making supplications [to the [[guru]] in this [[state]]] and habituating [to that], |
− | you and others, whatever exists – all of samsara and nirvana – | + | you and others, whatever [[exists]] – all of [[samsara and nirvana]] – |
− | become one mind, spontaneously present, single, | + | become one [[mind]], spontaneously {{Wiki|present}}, single, |
− | free from something to be meditated and meditating, | + | free from something to be [[meditated]] and [[meditating]], |
− | without the hopes and fears of losing and obtaining results, | + | without the [[Wikipedia:Hope|hopes]] and {{Wiki|fears}} of losing and obtaining results, |
− | free from “I,” “mine,” | + | free from “I,” “mine,” “[[subject]] and [[object]],” |
− | and without [merely] imagining to be separate [from that] or not. | + | and without [merely] [[Wikipedia:Imagination|imagining]] to be separate [from that] or not. |
You are, without interruption, | You are, without interruption, | ||
− | the spontaneously present svabhavikakaya. | + | the spontaneously {{Wiki|present}} [[svabhavikakaya]]. |
− | Dedicate the merit afterwards | + | Dedicate the [[merit]] afterwards |
− | and also at other occasions for [the obtaining of] great awakening. | + | and also at other occasions for [the obtaining of] [[great awakening]]. |
− | The way to make the dedication is this: | + | The way to make the [[dedication]] is this: |
− | “May all beings achieve in every possible way the excellence | + | “May all [[beings]] achieve in every possible way the [[excellence]] |
− | of whatever virtue exists of all beings, | + | of whatever [[virtue]] [[exists]] of all [[beings]], |
which has been achieved, will be achieved, and is being achieved | which has been achieved, will be achieved, and is being achieved | ||
− | on the stages of that excellence.” | + | on the stages of that [[excellence]].” |
− | Thus, you must dedicate the root of virtue. | + | Thus, you must dedicate the [[root]] of [[virtue]]. |
− | This pith instruction of the Precious One | + | This [[pith instruction]] of the [[Precious One]] |
− | has been written requested by an excellent being. | + | has been written requested by an {{Wiki|excellent}} being. |
− | May all beings obtain supreme awakening | + | May all [[beings]] obtain supreme [[awakening]] |
− | by the merit arising from that. | + | by the [[merit]] [[arising]] from that. |
− | [This text, which] has been requested by Gompa Yeshe Tseg from the precious Guru, the Glorious Drigungpa, is complete. | + | [This text, which] has been requested by [[Gompa]] Yeshe Tseg from the [[precious]] [[Guru]], the Glorious [[Drigungpa]], is complete. |
− | Byang chub sems gnyis nyams su blang ba’i gdams ngag ye shes rtsegs la gnang ba ‘Jig-rten-mgon-po’i gSung ‘bum, vol. kha, pp. 275-280. | + | [[Byang chub sems]] [[gnyis]] [[nyams]] su blang ba’i [[gdams ngag]] [[ye shes]] rtsegs la gnang ba ‘Jig-rten-mgon-po’i gSung ‘bum, vol. kha, pp. 275-280. |
Line 202: | Line 202: | ||
− | 1. [Tib. dge ba, lit. | + | 1. [Tib. [[dge ba]], lit. “[[existing]] [[virtue]].” The [[Kagyüpas]] maintain the [[existence]] of [[virtue]] within [[the nature of reality]], which is the [[Buddha nature]], and which can be dedicated to [[awakening]]. |
− | The Drugpa Kagyüpa use the term | + | The [[Drugpa]] [[Kagyüpa]] use the term “[[inherent]] [[virtue]]” ([[gnas]] pa’i [[dge ba]] ) and the [[Taklung]] [[Kagyüpas]] “natural [[virtue]]” ([[rang bzhin]] gyi [[dge ba]] ).]↩ |
− | 2. [Yuktishastika 6; P vol. 95, p. 11/2/8. The actual quote has some variants: srid pa dang ni mya ngan ‘das// gnyis po ‘di ni yod ma yin// srid pa yongs su shes pa nyid// mya ngan ‘das zhes bya bar brjod//. | + | 2. [Yuktishastika 6; P vol. 95, p. 11/2/8. The actual quote has some variants: [[srid pa]] dang ni mya [[ngan]] ‘das// [[gnyis]] po ‘di ni [[yod]] ma [[yin]]// [[srid pa]] yongs su [[shes pa]] [[nyid]]// mya [[ngan]] ‘das [[zhes bya]] bar brjod//. “[[Existence]] and [[nirvana]],// these two do not [[exist]].// Thoroughly [[knowing]] [[existence]]// is called ‘[[nirvana]].’” |
− | 3. My translation of bla ma’i dus mtha’ bsten pa as | + | 3. My translation of bla ma’i dus mtha’ bsten pa as “[[Wikipedia:Absolute (philosophy)|ultimate]] [[guru]] [[Wikipedia:sacrifice|sacrifice]]” reflects [[Jigten Sumgön’s]] [[teaching]] of [[Wikipedia:Absolute (philosophy)|ultimate]] [[guru devotion]] as [[seeing]] the [[guru]] as the [[dharmakaya]] |
Latest revision as of 10:38, 9 February 2020
This year, I have published much less on this blog because I have been very busy with a wonderful project at a Consortium of the University of Erlangen-Nürnberg called “Fate, Freedom and Prognostication: Strategies for Coping with the Future in East Asia and Europe.”
In this project, I have studied Central and East Asian divination texts and worked together with Solvej Hyveled Nielsen on a dice divination text of Achi Chökyi Dölma.
Solvej has also contributed a translation of a mala divination text of Tara that is ascribed to Atisha.
We hope that we will soon be able to present our book Divining with Achi and Tara, which will include a comparative study of dice divination, detailed interviews with Khenchen Nyima Gyaltsen Rinpoche and Lho Ontul Rinpoche, appendices on the specialised Tibetan terminology of divination and more.
This blog will now undergo a small transformation.
Instead of being solely devoted to Jigten Sumgön’s “Single Intention” (dGongs gcig), it will from now on be concerned with his teachings in general.
I will, therefore, soon migrate a few articles from my other blog, “The World of Jigten Sumgön,” to this blog.
In truth, whichever teaching of Jigten Sumgön we study, we will find that it always reflects the central idea that the teachings of all Buddhas have only one single intention.
The blog entry of today is concerned with Jigten Sumgön’s teaching of the two resolves for awakening (bodhicitta).
In agreement with the idea of the unity of all teachings, he maintains that the “two bodhicittas” are actually “of a single taste like sesame and sesame oil.”
Moreover, ultimately speaking, bodhicitta is not different from the absolute nature of reality, or Buddha nature, which is also the thing to be dedicated.
The teaching is brief but very profound.
Bestowing the pith instructions of cultivating the two resolves for awakening on Yeshe Tseg
Om swasti!
Respectfully I pay homage with my body to the feet of glorious Phagmodrupa, protector of the three worlds, and essence of the gnosis of body, speech, and mind of the Buddhas of the three times.
With a pure mind, I take refuge.
In general, to achieve supreme, completely awakened Buddhahood, there is nothing but the resolve for awakening whereby complete awakening can be obtained. If [the resolve] is lacking, that is a certain cause [for awakening] not to arise.
This resolve for awakening has two aspects.
From the point of view of cultivating the conventional resolve for awakening, when you engage in the cultivation of the root of immeasurably vast virtue – or, respectively, in the first morning session – you bless the three longer and shorter periods of time, thinking from the depth of your heart and the marrow of your bones:
May all sentient beings – my mothers who are as infinite as space – have happiness, be free from suffering, and obtain the precious, supreme, and complete awakening.
To achieve that, I will bind body, speech, and mind to virtue until I have obtained Buddhahood, I will bind body, speech, and mind to virtue until I die, and I will bind body, speech, and mind to virtue from today until tomorrow.
Then, for the practice, you should train all the roots of virtue of body, speech, and mind in terms of that intention.
Moreover, having cultivated the resolve for awakening in the morning or when you are at ease to do so, you must take the roots of virtue of
body, speech, and mind that implement that [[[intention]]] as an example and dedicate the virtue that is accumulated by you and all others in
the three times and the root of the virtue of true reality to complete awakening. That is the conventional resolve for awakening, the
intention of all masters of skill – the Buddhas of the three times – and the great treasure that will accomplish all temporary and ultimate
qualities. Therefore, you should cultivate the conventional resolve for awakening.
Now, how is the ultimate resolve for awakening practised?
The ultimate resolve for awakening is exactly that same conventional resolve for awakening, but free from the extremes of all proliferations of arising, ceasing, and abiding, the true reality.
Similarly, Acarya Arya [[[Nagarjuna]]], too, says:
Samsara and nirvana are not two.
Understanding the nature of samsara is called nirvana.
And the precious guru Phagmodrupa, too, says:
Complete pacification of proliferation is the absolute resolve for awakening.
[That and] conventional preliminary resolve and its actualization thoroughly moistened with compassion are of a single taste like sesame and sesame oil.
Therefore, [[[relative]] and absolute resolve] are to be known as inseparable.
And with that regard, even though there are systems of practicing [the absolute] as an emptiness where all things are discerned by way of
atoms and divisions of parts of atoms, we maintain that it is realised only by way of devotion to the excellent guru, since that is what has
been maintained by our precious guru [[[Phagmodrupa]]]. Similarly, the Exalted One has taught it in the Shri Hevajra Tantra:
That, which is not expressed by others, the inborn,
which one cannot find anywhere,
one must know through the ultimate guru sacrifice
and through one’s merit.
Therefore, we assert the essence of the nature of the mind to be without interruption when the meaning that is beyond expression and thought
and that is not the object of theoreticians – the inborn gnosis that is free from proliferation – has arisen as something that arises
naturally through the devotion to the excellent guru and by the gathering of the accumulation of merit that precedes that.
How is that practised? First, sit well on a comfortable seat in the cross-legged position and remain with the five limbs of concentration.
Then, first, cultivate the resolve for supreme awakening and cultivate the body as the deity of Mantra.
Then, meditate the excellent guru on the top of your head or in your heart and remain in a state of an unfabricated mind.
Do not grasp [the mind] as existing – that would be eternalism.
Do not meditate it as non-existent – that would be annihilism.
Do not meditate it “without grasping” – that would be “fabricated by the mind.”
Leave [the mind] fresh, unfabricated, and unbound.
From making supplications [to the guru in this state] and habituating [to that],
you and others, whatever exists – all of samsara and nirvana –
become one mind, spontaneously present, single,
free from something to be meditated and meditating,
without the hopes and fears of losing and obtaining results,
free from “I,” “mine,” “subject and object,”
and without [merely] imagining to be separate [from that] or not.
You are, without interruption,
the spontaneously present svabhavikakaya.
Dedicate the merit afterwards
and also at other occasions for [the obtaining of] great awakening.
The way to make the dedication is this:
“May all beings achieve in every possible way the excellence
of whatever virtue exists of all beings,
which has been achieved, will be achieved, and is being achieved
on the stages of that excellence.”
Thus, you must dedicate the root of virtue.
This pith instruction of the Precious One
has been written requested by an excellent being.
May all beings obtain supreme awakening
by the merit arising from that.
[This text, which] has been requested by Gompa Yeshe Tseg from the precious Guru, the Glorious Drigungpa, is complete.
Byang chub sems gnyis nyams su blang ba’i gdams ngag ye shes rtsegs la gnang ba ‘Jig-rten-mgon-po’i gSung ‘bum, vol. kha, pp. 275-280.
Notes
1. [Tib. dge ba, lit. “existing virtue.” The Kagyüpas maintain the existence of virtue within the nature of reality, which is the Buddha nature, and which can be dedicated to awakening.
The Drugpa Kagyüpa use the term “inherent virtue” (gnas pa’i dge ba ) and the Taklung Kagyüpas “natural virtue” (rang bzhin gyi dge ba ).]↩
2. [Yuktishastika 6; P vol. 95, p. 11/2/8. The actual quote has some variants: srid pa dang ni mya ngan ‘das// gnyis po ‘di ni yod ma yin// srid pa yongs su shes pa nyid// mya ngan ‘das zhes bya bar brjod//. “Existence and nirvana,// these two do not exist.// Thoroughly knowing existence// is called ‘nirvana.’”
3. My translation of bla ma’i dus mtha’ bsten pa as “ultimate guru sacrifice” reflects Jigten Sumgön’s teaching of ultimate guru devotion as seeing the guru as the dharmakaya