The Early Development of the Padmasambhava Legend in Tibet: A Study of Pelliot Tibétain

Journal of the American Oriental Society

hold that Padmasambhavaha always acted like a mirror ,perfectly reflecting what ever aspects of the Buddhist teachings are required by his faithful followers. Perhaps we too learn more by seeing Padmasambhava n this way,less as a historically locatable personthan as a shiftin gmatrix of meanings constantly calling for interpretation. BIBLIOGRAPHY Bischoff, EA.1978. Padmasambhava st-il unpersonnagehistorique? In Proceedings of the Csomade K6rds Symposium,ed. LouisLigeti.Pp.27-33.Budapest:Akaddmia iKiad6.Bischoff,EA.,and Charles Hartman.1971.Padmasambhava's ivention of the Phur-bu:Ms.PelliotTibdtain44.InEtudestibetainesd4dides a' amdmoirede Marcelle Lalou.Pp.11-27. Paris:Adrien Maisonneuve. Dalton,Jacob P.Forthcoming.A Crisis of Doxography:How Tibetans Organized Tantra during the 8th-12thCenturies.Journalofthe International Association of Buddhist Studies.Davidson,Ronald M. 2002. Indian Esoteric Buddhism.NewYork:Columbia Univ. Press.Dharmasri,Lochen.1975. 'Duspa'imdodbang spyidonrgyud ungmanngag gi gnadgsal byed sgronme. InCollected Works of Smin-glingLo-chenDharmaSri,vol. 12.Dehra Dun: D. G. Khocchen Trulku.

Dowman,Keith.1995. Power Places of Kathmandu Valley.London: Thames and Hudson. Dudjom Rinpoche.1991.The Nyingma School of Tibetan Buddhism,tr.Gyurme Dorje. Boston:Wisdom Publications.Germano,David.1994.Architecture and Absence in the Secret Tantric History of the Great Perfection.Journal of the International Associatio of Buddhist Studies 17:203-335.Germano, David,andJanetGyatso.2000.Longchenpa and the Dakinis.In Tantra n Practice,ed.David G. White.Pp.239-65. Princeton: Princeton Univ. Press.Granoff,Phyllis.2000. Other People's Rituals: Ritual Eclecticismin Early Medieval Indian Religions.Journal of Indian Philosophy28:399-424.Gr6nbold,Giinter.2001.'Saptavara'.ADharani Collection from Nepal.In Le Parole e iMarmi,ed.Raffaele Torella.Vol.1,pp.369-75. Rome: Istituto italian operl'Africael'Oriente.Guhyagarbha Tantra. Them Tshams-Brag Manuscript of the rNying-ma rgyud'bum . Vol.wa,ff.152.6-218.7.

Thimphu,Bhutan:National Library.Guhyasamaja Tantra,d. S.Bagchi.Darbhanga:Mithila Institute.Gunawardana,R.A.L. H.1979.Robe and Plough:Monasticism and Economic Interest in Early Medieval Sri Lanka. Tucson:Univ.of Arizona Press.Gyatso,Janet. 1987. Down with the Demoness: Reflections ona Feminine Ground in Tibet. Tibet Journal 12:38-53.Harper,Katherine Anne.1989.Seven Hindu Goddesses of Spiritual Transformation. ewiston,N.Y.:Edwin Mellen Press.Kapstein,Matthew. 2000. The Tibetan Assimilation of Buddhism.Oxford: Oxford Univ. Press.Karmay,Samten. 1988. The Great Perfection.Leiden: E. J. Brill.Macdonald,A.W.,and AnneV.Stahl.1979.Newar Art.Warminster:Aris & PhillipsLtd.Mayer,Robert. 1991. Observations on the Tibetan Phur-pa and the Indian kila. In Buddhis ForumII,ed. Tadeus Skorupski.Pp.163-92. London: School of Oriental and African Studies.Nebesky-Wojkowitz,Rend.1996. Oracles and Demons of Tibet. Delhi:Book Faith India.Panikkar,ShivajiK.1989.Saptamat.rka Worship and Sculptures.New Delhi: D. K. Print world Ltd.Przyluski,Jean. 1923. Les VidyarSija:Contribution i '

l'histoire de lamagiedansles sectes Mahaya-nistes. Bulletin del 'Ecolerangaised'Extrdme-Orient 3: 301-18. RongXinjiang.999-2000.TheNature f theDunhuang ibraryaveand heReasons or ItsSealing. Cahiers d 'Extrdme-Asie 1:247-75..2004.Official LifeatDunhuangin the TenthCentury:The Case of CaoYuanzhong.InThe Silk Road:Trade,Travel,WarandFaith,ed. Susan Whitfield.Pp.57-62.Chicago:SerindiaPublications.

DALTON:The Early Development of the Padmasambhava Legend in Tibet 771 Shaw,Julia.Forthcoming.Naga Sculptures nSanchi's Archaeologica lLandscape:Buddhism,Vaisnavism,andLocal Agricultural Cults in Central India,First CenturyB.C.E.o Fifth Century C.E.Arti-bus Asiae.Skjwervo,rods Oktor.Forth coming.Legal Documents Concerning Ownership and Sale from Eighth-century Khotan. In From Nisato Niya.New Discoveries and Studiesin Central and Inner Asian Art and Archaeology,ed. M.Ghose andL.Russell-Smith. London:SaffronPress.Spiro,MelfordE.1978. Burmes Supernaturalism.Philadelphia:Institute for the Study of Human Issues.Takeuchi,Tsuguhito.2004.Sociolinguistic Implications of the Use of Tibetan in East Turkestan rom the End of Tibetan Domination throug hhe Tangut Period (9th-12thc.).In Proceedings of"Turfan Revisited-The First Century of Research into the Arts and Culture of the Silk Road,"ed.Desmond Durkin-Meisterernst t al. Berlin: Museum fir Indische Kunst.Tsogyal,Yeshe. 1993. The Lotus Born: The Life Story of Padmasambhava,r. Erik Pema Kunsang.Boston:ShambalaPublications.Tucci,Giuseppe.1949. Painted Scrolls.Rome:LibreriadelloStato.Vall6ePoussin,Louis dela.1962.Catalogue ofthe Tibetan Manuscripts rom Tun-huangn the India Office Library.London: Oxford Univ. Press.vanShaik,Sam.2002. The Tibetan Dunhuan g Manuscriptsn China. Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies 65: 129-39.Wangdu, Pasang,and Hildegard Diemberger.2000. dBa'bzhed:The Royal Narrative Concerning the Bringing of the Buddha's Doctrine to Tibet.Vienna:Verlagder Osterreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften.Wessing,Robert,and RoyE. Jordaan.1997. Death at the Building Site: Construction Sacrificen South-east Asia.History of Religions37:101-21.Wylie,Turrell.1970.A Tibetan Religiou Geography of Nepal.Rome:Istituto Italianoperil Medio ed Estrem Oriente.Yamaguchi,Zuih6.1996.The Fiction of KingDar-ma'sPersecution of Buddhism.In Du Dunhuangau Japon:Etude chinoisesetbouddhiquesoffertes ai MichelSoymid,ed. Jean-PierreDrege.Pp.231-58. Geneva: Droz.APPENDIXTRANSCRIPTIONFPADMASAMBHAVAASSAGEFROMPELLIOTTIBtiTAIN07,LINES10-32@/:/rdorjekungragsma/skumdog nagmomang dgyessamthugsdamskongsnanabza'darrmagsol/ rgyangzhanlayangsnatshogskyisbrgyan palgzugsmdzesshing sdug parston /myidgyeslathugsdamskongsnanagmo ralpacantre'ulabcibs/rkonglademo zheskyang bgyi/'di bdungyigtsomolags//rdorjekun tubzangskumdodkarmocangshes dkarpo'igdanlabzhugs shingthugsdamkha chuladgyes/shamyedgangsdkarzheskyang bgyi/rdorjekungsalma/ skumdogsnarmona bza'gtsos gsol/rtasngon polabcibs/ lha rig.ya'maskyolzheskyang bgyi//rdorje yeshesmchog/skumdogsnar mo nabza'snatshogsgsol//mdzo mosprultebcibs/brda' labtsan mo zhesbgyi/rdorje sgronma/nabza'gtsos gsol gdan/ smyan sprultebcibs/kharag khyungbtsun zhesbgyi/rdorje'odchagsma/skubdogdmar mo na bza'gtsos gsol//gdankhri 'bri khamyusprultebcigs/byang gigser tangyige'khor'dulmazhesbgyi/rdorje g.yu sgronma/skumdog sngonmogdankhri rtasngonposprultebcibs/lho'iting tingzhesbgyi'o/

772Journalofthe American OrientalSociety124.4(2004)

@/:/'dibdunyangmkhagromazheskyangbgyi/shug 'groma zheskyang bgyi/ma chen mo bdunzheskyangbgyi/srin mochen mobdun zheskyang bgyistel/thogma nidkyil'khorrnamgnyisbshamsshingbyungbadang/matangru ta bthulba'ile'udanglas//damstsolzhinglassubskoste//durkhrod chenpophye dangbdunsrungba'isrungsmar/ /herukas bka'stsolto//deyangchenchung'dra' ba'itshogsso//deslanchadnidpal gyi yanggzungsdampa'o//de'i'ogdunirgyagargyimkhanpo padma sam ba badang/ rlang dpalgyi seng ge gnyis kyisbtulcingdambrnantel/bodkhamsgyibdagmo'dirnamslagdurdorjebyinnas rdorje 'chang gigraldumying btagsso/ /denasgzhungbzhingsangsngagssgrub parnamskyimthudangstong grogs bgyidpa dang/bod khamsmtharmyi'jigpa'i srungsmarbcolzhing/ sringmoyangyin/chejechen mornamskyiszhalgyisbzhesshing/dam bcasso//damtsigkha chu ladga'/mchodpalhagladgyesso/bsgombadangrdzasdagnantan cherbgyi'tshal/Vphyagmtshanyang 'jigstshulrnatshogs pa thogsso/(b)ar'ga'niphyagmtshansdugcingmdzespa thogsso///bdag nyidchen mordorjekungragsma/gangsdkarshamyedrdorjekuntubzang/dpalIdanIharirdorjekungsalma/brda' la btsan mordorje yeshesmchog/kharagkhyungbtsunrdorje sgronma zhe'o/byanggigser tangrdorje'odchagsma/lho'iting tingrdorjeg.yusgronma//semscandonphyir'phagspa'ispyan sngar khyed//dambcaskhas'chesgang yinde

Itargyis//dkonmchogbslussam/yangna damnyamsnalrang rgyud sreg cing dmyalmyeskyig.ya'ba'i//'jigschenmyibzadde soms'dirgshegsla//zhi/rgyas/

dbangdang/mngonspyodlaskyirnams//rdzogs parmdzodlaskyon myed grub par gyis//